I haven’t done one of these posts in a long time, but here goes: a complaining post about one of my sisters is coming at ya. I honestly don’t even have the time, energy or even desire to deal with it, but I thought I’d share the latest saga, all over the name of the boy twin.
So, back story here, my husband and I are pretty traditional. Especially when it comes to matters of our Italian heritage. The way we named our 1st born son was to name him after my husband’s father. That’s just what you do. Subsequent children are to be named after the father’s side first (yeah, sexist, but that’s the way it is and I’m ok with it) and then the mother’s side. So, since we’re having boy/girl twins, the girl gets my husband’s mother’s name (not a fan of it, but that’s ok, I’ll have a good nickname), and then the boy would get my father’s name.
One problem, though. My youngest sister (the feistiest one of them all) already named her 7-year-old son my father’s name. But, this is not unheard of in Italian families. Cousins have the same name to honor the grandfather. My dad had 5 cousins with his same name. My mom had 3. This is normal. My sisters like to pretend they’re not Italian anymore because they all married non-Italians (not that there’s anything wrong with that) but they like to pretend that they don’t know this rule.
Anyway, my sister had forbid me early on, “Don’t name your son the same name as mine!” and I had conceded at the time, but…and here’s the thing…I’ve thought about it for a long time now and I just can’t find a name that has as much meaning as my father’s. As it stands now, my husband will have honored both his parents with our children’s names, and I will not get my father in there at all b/c, well, let’s face it, I am scared of my sister.
I’ve been talking to my parents about it and they’re actually on board with using my father’s name. My father, honestly, doesn’t care, but he admits that it’s nice that we’d be traditional. And besides, after all my father has been through lately, it just makes sense in my heart to honor him now, more than ever. After passing this past my parents, I decided I had to stop being afraid of my sister and let her know that I just *might” use my father’s name–also her son’s name–for my son. I told my parents I knew my sister wouldn’t be happy, but they said, don’t worry, she’ll be fine.
So, things get a little more interesting. I had asked her a couple of weeks ago if she would be the godmother to my son. She accepted. Now, in order to be a godmother, she needs to get a signed statement from her church to say she’s a member of the church, and they always ask the name of the child to put on this statement. So, knowing this, I called her and told her the news.
I said, “Listen, I think we’re going to name the boy after Dad.” To which she replied as if I had just killed her son. She told me that wasn’t right and it’s not fair to her son. (She basically made me feel like I’d be causing undue stress to my own nephew!) I told her we’d use a different nickname than her son but then she got all crazy. She said, “What if he wants to change his nickname when he’s older?!” And I was like, “ok, what does this change? These cousins will be 7 years apart. They’ll hardly interact with each other. They won’t go to the same school. You know we like to do things the traditional way and it makes sense to honor dad now more than ever…” To which she replied, “oh yeah, what about mom, you’re not using her name…” I stayed calm, but schooled her on the way (SHE KNOWS) we Italians do things. “Um, she’s getting the girls middle name…and oh, by the way, did you ever use mom’s name at all with your daughter?” The answer was no of course.
Ok, so fine. I was calm, telling her that I wanted to honor dad with all he’s been through, and she basically said, “you’re so selfish, you only think about yourself” and then she hung up on me. That was a lovely conversation. I wasn’t surprised in the slightest.
The next day I get the following text from her:
“I think you should know if you name the baby [the same name as my son] it will hurt my relationship with you very much. I just think you should know that. And I don’t want you making a scene at [my daughter’s birthday] party [this weekend] because that’s not fair to her.”
I was at Target with my son. Once I read this I started laughing, honestly. I can’t even get angry anymore with them. So I replied, “Um, I think you’re the one making a scene”
FYI, the insinuation here is that not only am I causing undue stress to her son, but now I am such a monster that I’d cause mental anguish to her daughter, my goddaughter, btw! Jeez, what kind of horrible aunt am I? Believe me, I wouldn’t even dream of bringing anything up. I would never make my own nieces and nephews special day about me, unlike my sister. The fact that she’s making it out to be that I would is really hurtful, again!
Next, she says, “And you should probably find a new god mother because I won’t get over [this] and that’s not fair to him”
So now, the whole godmother thing really bothered me. I think it’s pretty low to withdraw from such an honor, ESPECIALLY KNOWING EVERYTHING WE’VE BEEN THROUGH TO GET HERE! Is it possible that my sister is this selfish, this pathetic that she has nothing else going on in her life than to fight for her son’s right to hypothetical nicknames when he’s 12? C’mon! My husband was so angry and fed up that he basically told me right then and there to just find another godmother. I just don’t want to be as nasty as she is though. Am I wrong? Couldn’t she have handled this better?
So, now that my sister has put such a bad taste in my mouth with this whole name thing, I basically went back to my parents and asked them what they thought I should do, but honestly, I was over the name. Not because I want to give in to her, oh no, but just because she ruined it for me. My parents said I should keep strong and keep the name, but if I did, this will be all I can think about–how nasty my sister was when I wanted to use my father’s name (it’s not her son’s name, it’s MY FATHER’S NAME) as my own son’s name.
This is the solution I’ve come up with. My husband and I have decided on a hybrid name. It will begin in a way as to signify my father’s, but then have a different ending (you can do this, kinda, with this particular name, think “Gian” names in Italian.) Is this 100% honoring my father? No, but I guess it’s the best I can do. The nickname will be totally different, not even remotely close to my nephew’s, but, the first initial will be the same. This is how I’ll pose it to her. She’ll have to decide whether or not she still wants to be the godmother or not. I’ll tell her the baby’s name will start with a “G”. Little does she know it’s a different name, but she’ll have to take the leap of faith. Is it still my father’s name, or another name? It’s up to her to decide if she wants to be petty enough to bow out of the honor or prove to me that it really means something to her. To me, it’s always been something I’ve wanted, to have all 3 of my sisters be godmother’s to my children. My 1st son’s godmother is my older sister, the girl twin will get my 1st younger sister, and then the boy SHOULD get my youngest sister. I’ve always told them this. Granted, I never knew I’d actually have 3 children, but this line of thinking always got me through the darkest days of infertility: knowing that things could work out this way! I am lucky enough to be a godmother to one each of their children, and I take that as an honor. Guess it means nothing to them.
Anyway, we shall see what happens. I’m just so over the drama in the family. Now’s not the time for this petty SHIT! I thought it was all over and I thought we were getting closer and letting stupid things go, especially with what’s been going on with our father. Life is WAY to short for this, but at the same time, it’d be nice to know that my own sister really wants to be the godmother to my child. Time will tell.