His last days
I was in Detroit when I received a short message from Dr. Annisa Jusuf (cordially known as Bu Icha, an associate professor at ITB and a colleague of Prof. Bambang). The message came early, at 5:33 A.M., on November 25, 2024, in the cold winter. She forwarded a message saying, “Prof. Bambang Kismono was admitted to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) of Borromeus Hospital Bandung…”
Bambang was lying unconscious in the ICU on Level 4 of Borromeus Hospital. At that instant, I calmly responded, believing that he would be better as soon as the doctors at Borromeus attended to his critical condition. I started to inquire about the cause of his condition. She helped gather some information, saying that a stroke had hit him. His other medical histories were primarily known to Bambang and his immediate family, which was understandable, as I knew him as a private person. However, I prayed for his recovery, reciting Yaa-sin, one surah in the Quran, and hoping that God the Almighty would ease his suffering. Despite all efforts exerted to his recovery, Prof. Bambang passed away on Monday, December 2, 2024, at 7:13 PM local time. He was 64 years old and survived by his wife, Erly. They had no children. My wife, who was with me at the time, helped me search for a variety of flowers and sent them to his home address, Jl. Sangkuriang S-3, RT 02/RW 12, Kompleks ITB, Bandung.
On Tuesday, December 3, 2024, Borromeous Hospital delivered his body at 8 A.M. to Salman Mosque, receiving a salat al-mayyit, an Islamic funeral prayer for the deceased. At 9:30 A.M., his body was delivered to the Aula Barat ITB (West Wing of ITB), which is located across the street from the Salman Mosque. It was heartwarming to see the photos that showed so many people attending this prayer and paying tribute to him for the last time. He was buried in the Cibarunai Public Memorial Park, Sukajadi, Bandung.
Personal life
Bambang was born on September 4, 1960, in Yogyakarta, a special province around Central Java. I knew very little about him except that he was the eldest among his siblings. His parents, either one or both, were teachers, so he grew up in a family of educators. He went to study at SMAN 1, one of the best high schools in Yogyakarta. He was admitted to ITB’s Department of Mechanical Engineering in 1979. During his college years, he enjoyed reading books and writing articles for the newspaper, for example, Sinar Harapan.
Academic life
Bambang’s interest in academics was likely nurtured by Prof. Sulaeman Kamil, a professor in the Mechanical Engineering Department at ITB. Not only that, Bambang was closely trained by Prof. Sulaeman Kamil, who served as the Director of Technology at the Nusantara Aircraft Industry (Industri Pesawat Terbang Nusantara, IPTN) in Bandung, to take over the baton for the development of composite materials at ITB for the years to come. Kamil, who completed his Ph.D. in Mechanical Engineering from Ohio State University in 1977, took an introductory course about composite materials and manufacturing methods in the early 1970s from Prof. Henry R. Velkoff (a close friend of Igor Sikorsky, a renowned helicopter designer in the U.S.). Moreover, Kamil met Prof. Huba Ory from Germany, who delivered a seminar on composites analysis when he visited ITB and IPTN. Kamil continued his interest by taking a one-week course on composite materials with Prof. Stephen Tsai at Stanford University in California. As his interest in composites grew, he assigned Bambang to work on the undergraduate final-year project, developing finite element codes written in Fortran to analyze the stress distribution in open-hole composite specimens with different ply orientations.
Bambang received an Insinyur (Ir.) degree, equivalent to a bachelor’s degree in engineering, in 1986. After that, he worked at ITB as a young lecturer between 1987 and 1989. In 1989, he completed his advanced course in composites manufacturing at Delft University of Technology (TU Delft), the Netherlands. He then enrolled at Imperial College London, UK, in 1990. He received his M.Sc. and Ph.D. from the Department of Aeronautics, Imperial College London, United Kingdom, in 1991 and 1995, respectively. He returned to ITB in 1996.
Administrative work at ITB
In addition to teaching and research duties, he was very active in the administrative side of the university, within and outside ITB. He had the opportunity to be assigned to hold various posts. He was appointed as the secretary of the department (associate department head) from 2001 to 2003 and as head of the department from 2003 to 2005. He was involved in winning the research proposal with Prof. Ichsan Setya Putra on the buckling of a structure project. Bambang’s interest in the military and defense enabled him to join an exceptional team that established a defense study program at ITB, with support from Cranfield University in the United Kingdom and Justus-Liebig-Universität Giessen in Germany. He also joined a special team to establish the Indonesia Defence University (Universitas Pertahanan) in Bogor from 2009 to 2011. In 2013, he served as the faculty senate secretary for the Faculty of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering. During his service at ITB, he was awarded various decorations. He received a dedication award from ITB for his dedication: Satya Lancana Karya Satya (SLKS) for 10-year dedication (August 19, 2004), SLKS for 20-year dedication (August 6, 2013), ITB Award for 25-year dedication (August 14, 2014), SLKS for 30-year dedication (August 13, 2020), and ITB Award for 35-year dedication (July 29, 2024).
Learning from him
I vividly remember enjoying his “Analysis of Lightweight Structures” course. I kept applying for another course of his. I was enrolled in his “Mechanics of Composites Structures” course, and I went on to take an elective course from him, titled “Theory of Structural Stability.” I thoroughly enjoyed and loved all the courses that he taught. The way he delivered the course was, to me, at least, a storytelling style. Of course, it was filled with mathematical formulation. Still, finding someone who patiently wrote a long-winding derivation and reached a closed-form solution was enjoyable.
Bambang as a thesis advisor
I had an unusual reason for selecting Bambang as my academic supervisor for my final-year undergraduate project. It was due to his patience and unassuming traits, rather than his initial expertise in composites and buckling. He spoke with a soft intonation characteristic of people originally from Central Java, which was diametrically different from mine. His soft-spoken style was periodically flavored with excitement, fun expression, and optimism. People would enjoy talking with him on a variety of topics. I personally enjoyed our conversation.
In August 2001, I went to his office with my close friend, Ade Fajar. Our intention was to take one project and work on the undergraduate thesis. Ade Fajar was assigned to work on the finite element analysis of sandwich panels subjected to a concentrated load. His objective was to calculate the deformation of the dimple caused by the concentrated load. The topic for Ade Fajar was selected by Bambang from a proceeding paper written by Prof. Meyer-Piening from ETH Zurich. I remember Bambang telling us about his conference trip to Switzerland with his wife. It was simply a beautiful country. However, my thesis topic was less clear. Bambang asked me if I could visit UAVINDO, a small startup located at ITB, and find a topic related to unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to work on. Before that, I visited Prof. Djoko Sardjadi, the director of UAVINDO. He told me I should talk to Jupriyanto, a recent ITB graduate who worked at UAVINDO, handling a structural/material subject related to unmanned aerial vehicles. Jupriyanto was a kind, helpful, and knowledgeable person. He told me I should work on the stress analysis of the UAV composite wing structure. I was advised to use the ‘Bruhn method’ to calculate the stresses at the skin of the wing structure. I diligently worked on the project and performed all the calculations in Microsoft Excel (something that UAVINDO would eventually like to have).
Two things struck me out of the blue, making me consider changing the subject. First, whenever I met Prof. Bambang for advice with Ade Fajar, I did not see the excitement in his eyes. I would guess that stress analysis using the Bruhn method was not unique. He liked something unique. Whenever I saw him looking at the finite element results that Ade Fajar brought, he was ecstatic. It was a completely different game. The second thing was a bit of a change from the UAVINDO side. Prof. Djoko Sardjadi told me that he was more interested in the crashworthiness of the UAV wing structure. He advised me to speak with Prof. Bambang and asked me how to proceed with the graduation. The additional work would take an extra semester to complete.
Prof. Bambang said I could work on something else, as crashworthiness was not his area of expertise at the time. Moreover, he said I should be a PhD student if I wanted to continue on that path. Ultimately, the conclusion was that I had dropped the ball on the UAV stress analysis. I knew that there would be some disappointment from the UAVINDO side. But working on something that was not my league or interest was hard for me. I spoke with Jupriyanto about this, and he completely respected that decision. Prof. Bambang discussed the change with Prof. Djoko, and he seemed to understand it. Then, my “life” changed in January after my short break in December 2001.
Adventure in the sandwich world
My new topic was the buckling of sandwich structures. This time, he again showed me the proceeding paper that Prof. Meyer-Piening had written. He asked me if I could model the face sheet wrinkling of a sandwich structure subjected to compressive loading, similar to what Prof. Meyer-Piening has in the paper. He handed me several documents about the buckling and wrinkling of sandwich structures, most of which were his own, published in Composite Structures, one of the reputable journals in composites. I told him I was interested in the topic, although I was unsure if I could solve it. But I would try.
He had a new position as a department secretary at that time, so he occupied a new office on the third floor. His office on the fourth floor was thus empty. He told me that I could use the latest computer and his room. He obtained the computer from Prof. Ichsan Setya Putra as part of their project on buckling aircraft structures with patches. M. Ridha, my cohort friend who completed his thesis 6 months earlier, helped me install the computer. We then installed the finite element software MSC.Nastran for Windows v. 45. I went to Ade Fajar’s house and learned from him about building a 3D finite element model in MSC.Nastran. It ran well on his PC. Ade Fajar, who attained his degree in December 2001, was busy looking for a job. Sometimes, I saw him on campus, and I took the opportunity to consult with him about my finite element model. He kindly helped me with a few things in the model. At that time, Prof. Bambang advised another student, Indra Hastoadi Nugroho. He worked on the deformation of the fuselage cross-section (made of a sandwich structure) due to internal pressure. I recall that he achieved a reasonably good result compared to the existing literature. So, he passed the exam held sometime in May or June 2002.
I worked on buckling the sandwich structure between January and May 2002. However, for 3 months, I could not get a good result (at all!). There was always an error message after running the simulation for 20 to 40 hours. Meanwhile, Prof. Bambang, who was understandably excited about the outcome, would constantly come to me every day and ask if I had a new result. The answer was predictable: I had not obtained a good result.
He was actually more patient than I was. He advised me to send emails to three people who were considered experts in buckling sandwich structures at that time: Prof. Meyer-Piening (ETH Zurich), Dr. Ing. Walter Vonach (Vienna University of Technology), and Dr. Linus Fagerberg (a PhD candidate in KTH Sweden at that time). All of them kindly helped me with my problems despite my limited English. In addition, I also contacted Dr. Erwan Karyadi (an Indonesian gentleman who worked at MSC.Dytran, the Netherlands). I made frequent contact with them, who provided me with numerous suggestions on developing my FE models.
Finally, I obtained reasonably good results in April and made my way to speed up all the computations I had to run. I wrote my thesis in three weeks and defended it in June 2002. I was happy to have graduated and received my degree. After the defense, they advised me to pursue a master’s or PhD degree overseas. Prof. Ichsan offered me to study at one of the universities in Japan (Toyohashi Institute of Technology), South Korea (Konkuk University), Taiwan (I can’t remember the name), or Singapore (National University of Singapore). I chose the National University of Singapore. That morning, my brother, who was waiting outside the seminar room, entered the room, shook my hand, and took a photo of me, Prof. Bambang, and Dr. M. Giri Suada.
To be continued…


