It feels like he has articulated some of the issues I have struggled with as I try to find a balance between the conservative and fundamentalist Christianity I've been a part of most of my life and the "crazy liberal" ruminations of various bloggers and writers I seek out, who are struggling with the many flaws of Protestant Evangelicalism.
In this post, Witherington is interacting with RHE's latest book, and he has many specific comments to make about it (good and bad), but I found his comments to speak to a much larger issue.
How does the Church minister to this generation of searching people? Many who grew up in the church are, as adults, hungry for transparency, for "realness" that they didn't see as children. I don't have the words to respond to this article or book, but I wanted to pull out a few choice quotes:
Witherington:
But the church should never never become just like an AA meeting (one suggestion in this book). Why not? Because while we need such meetings, the church should not be focusing on our own brokenness and mainly sharing about that. We should be focusing on His brokenness when he hung on the cross, precisely so we will get away from our self-centered fixation with our own flaws and foibles. The church needs to be relentlessly theocentric in its worship, fellowship, and praxis, not anthropocentric.
On this conflation:
What her book fails to really grapple with however is the major difference between unconditional love and unconditional acceptance of us as we are.
A loving welcome by Jesus does not exclude incredible demands in regard to our conduct, and indeed even in regard to the lusts of our hearts.