
I don’t know if I’ve mentioned it here, but I am an enormous fan of The Expanse. I have read and listened to the books multiple times, and watched the series probably getting close to double figures. I am part way through the comics (though these are not written by the same authors). I admit, I haven’t played the Telltale game, but that’s more about me not liking Telltale games than anything.
I was recently watching a YouTube discussing the science of the show. Now while I’m not an astrophysicist or such, I do have some understanding of physics through other parts of my life (pilot training for example). The Expanse universe does have a couple of “made up for plot” devices, like most sci-fi shows. However, while the effect is significant (mostly their Epstein Drive, and the whole protomolecule and aliens) they are actually very restrained. I mean that they don’t use some made up thing to explain everything.
There are several YouTube videos that discuss the well thought out and accurate portrayals of physics within the show. Effects of acceleration, the speed of light and the enormous distances just within our solar system are usually high on this list.
This isn’t what annoyed me.
It’s the “The show did this, the show did that, they even thought to include this real physics………” and so on.

The show did this because THE BOOKS DID IT THAT WAY! The authors, (authors, because S.A. Corey is a pseudonym for two writers: Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck) wrote the books to include all this real physics and it OFTEN plays a significant role in the plot.
Now I’ll give credit to the show to keep it they way that they did. They could have taken the ideas in the books, added artificial gravity, instant communications, warp drive, laser weapons and teleportation and created something quite different. I’m sure sticking to some of the ‘rules’ cost extra money and time. But I think you would have ended up with something quite different to The Expanse as all this real world physics often creates the story’s scene and creates some (or a lot) of the dramatic tension in the story. Changing that may have ended up with a show that was SO MUCH LESS than the books (which happens so often).
I would just like these YouTubers to also acknowledge that a lot of this reality is because the AUTHORS of the BOOKS made it this way in the beginning.
And maybe more people will read the books.
Because they are really good.

They do have some differences, especially later in the stories, but they are really good.
So go read them if you haven’t.
Or listen to the audiobooks, these are excellent too.
















