I resisted watching The Chosen till my brother recommended it recently. My brother is a Calvinist, but I did not associate the name with that. I was just skeptical that it would do a good enough job with the New Testament as most don’t. I have written that The Passion did lead me eventually to the Orthodox Church.
By the way, I have also written about my estrangement with my family of origin since shortly after our conversion to Orthodoxy. Last summer, July 16, my father passed away suddenly with a brain bleed. My mother called me, and we came and got her from Louisiana. She is now living with us, and my brother comes over frequently, and we watch shows sometimes.
So I gave it a try. I was immediately impressed by the deep dive into Jesus’ early ministry, Judaism, and the ingénue apostles. I like their careful “plausible” over strictly Biblical approach. We did not like how St John the Baptist came off, however. I’m also not sure why they did not portray Christ’s Baptism or Transfiguration either. In the first seasons they were being more subtle with Christ’s divinity, but still, those were witnessed events.
Despite this, the low, slow approach in the series is more meditative of Christ’s and his apostles’ and followers’ lives. I found myself liking to dwell on it in this immersive way. Jonathan Roumie, who plays Jesus and is Catholic, is a practicer of meditation. And he looks somewhat like the Sinai icon of Christ.
In watching interviews with the cast on YouTube, I have learned that Jonathan Roumie was cradle Greek Orthodox, but when his family moved, they raised him Catholic, since that was what his Irish mother was. He says he feels more at home with the Catholic Church.
The Australian actor who plays John, well I’ll let Grok explain it:
“The actor who plays John in The Chosen is George Harrison Xanthis. He was raised Greek Orthodox and has spoken about reconnecting with his faith through his role in the series. While he describes himself as having been a “cultural Christian” at times, his work on The Chosen deepened his engagement with Christianity, particularly within the Greek Orthodox tradition.”
I think they all have spoken about how much more they have learned about theology, the culture and the humanity of Jesus’ disciples, if not his own. Xanthis seems to lament not learning it at Church. I have very fond memories of the good Protestant Sunday School teachers who made Bible stories come to life in my youth.
They really stepped it up with Season 5, The Last Supper though. I’ll go so far as to say it rivals, if not surpasses Da Vinci’s. But please watch the previous seasons first so you’ll appreciate each actors’ affect.