In an unjust world, I used to find hope in teaching.
Before I truly begin, let me first clearly state: This new found lack of hope, it has nothing to do with my students. They are not the problem. I do not subscribe to any “kids these days” beliefs. Are kids today different than they used to be? Absolutely! Is that the problem? Absolutely not. That’s just how a changing world works. But that’s a discussion for another day.
And now that that is out of the way, let me get back to where I am. To where we are.
In an unjust world, I used to find hope in teaching.
I believe that we have been building this unjust world that we find ourselves in for centuries now. We did not just find ourselves here. Where we are now, it is a result of all the injustice this county has been founded and built upon. And here we are.
And so now I sit here, in the suburbs right outside of Chicago and each night I go to sleep, or try to go to sleep, with my head filled with the stories of injustice that are unfolding in our neighborhoods, in our communities, in our streets and in our cities. Parents and caretakers are being taken while they are bringing their children to school. Schools are going on lockdown because ICE agents are lined up in trucks outside of the building at dismissal time. Teachers are trying to shield their young students from witnessing the kidnapping of those who care for them. People are being thrown to the ground, arrested, dragged off from the lives they have built, by those who have been given power by our government.
To be unaffected by this, is to be unhuman. The injustice is palpable.
And in these greatest moments of injustice, I try to find hope and seek solace where I can. I find solace in community, I find hope in those who are doing the work to care for and protect others and always, always, always I find all of the hope and solace in the ways that young people demand that this world do better.
And, in the past, perhaps my greatest source of hope has always come from being a teacher. For the past two decades, when the world has felt devoid of hope, I turned to the work I did in my classroom. When it has felt like we are powerless to create positive change, I have felt empowered by the fact that I am a teacher. My classroom has been ground zero for my resistance against injustice.
And I know that there are some who will read that and instantly claim that I have been indoctrinating students. And I have come to understand that those are people who I simply cannot argue with. Because to label resisting injustice as indoctrination causes me to question who and what you are really trying to protect and makes it clear that the way we view the world and our role in it is just too far apart.
So this writing. This is not for them.
I suppose this writing is for those who are feeling this same loss of hope. For those who have seen what is happening in our schools and in our classrooms and who feel the same frustration or for those who are unaware of what is happening in our schools and in our classrooms who, perhaps, when they better understand will come to want to demand that we do better.
Because in the past, in this current moment of ICE and the ways in which they are kidnapping and disappearing people off the streets, I would have turned to my teaching in order to counterattack the horrible messages that are filling young people about immigrants and their families.
I would have resisted the images that I know my students are seeing by flooding their minds with positive images of all sorts of people, from all sorts of places and the ways in which immigrants enhance our country and build our communities. I would have resisted the current trend of silencing any critical voice by teaching my students the ways in which they can ask critical questions of the information they are being bombarded with. And I would have resisted the ways in which those with power send messages that protecting their own privilege is more important than protecting those who are most vulnerable by teaching my students the skills they need to care for themselves and to care for others and their community.
This is how I have found hope. In resisting the current world by teaching my students how to build a better one.
But now. Things have changed.
Because now, in so many ways. Teachers’ hands are tied. Now, teachers no longer can weave together the academic skills that students need to learn with the work in the world that makes those skills meaningful. Now, teachers no longer can select texts that are relevant to the current moment and meet the needs of the students sitting alongside us. Now, teachers can no longer take the social emotional learning standards that states provide and craft lessons that teach those standards while using them to help kids make sense of the mess of a world they are living in.
Because now, teachers are not trusted as professionals. Now, teachers are being treated more like robots. The curriculum has been scripted for us. It comes in a box and it comes in a binder and it comes in workbook after workbook. Instead of seeing the world as it is and crafting lessons that help students to process it all, now we turn to the next page, in the next teacher guide, in the next workbook and we just keep moving because that is what teaching has become. Moving through the curriculum.
And I believe that this is by design. Those who have traditionally held power, they don’t want our young people learning how to question. They are uncomfortable with young people learning to read critically and view the world critically. Because when young people learn to do that, then they will come to decide for themselves what is just and what is right and who needs to be protected. And that does not often favor those who have held power in the past. So those who have held power in the past, they have a real interest in maintaining the status quo. So under the guise of “protecting our children,” they have found ways to protect themselves. And under the guide of “getting back to basics,” they have found ways to over emphasize concrete skills at the cost of allowing students to grow the more abstract skills of critically thinking and questioning the world around them through the texts that they read and the writing that they compose.
And I worry what this means for all of us. And that leaves me with this growing sense of a lack of hope.
But I know that I cannot give up. I know that is what those who have traditionally held power are hoping for. And I also know that I have to stay safe. So my resistance these days, it looks really different. To be an educator right now who is committed to social justice in a world that is, in so many ways, decidedly against it, is to be required to find new ways to resist.
So I resist in the ways that I treat my students. I resist in the ways I ask that they treat each other. I resist in the ways I emphasize community care above rules and punishment. I resist in the questions that I continue to ask. I resist in the words that I choose to hang on my walls. I resist in the books that I choose to put on my shelves. I resist in the ways that I model owning my impact and repairing harm when I cause it. I resist in the ways I respond to micro-agressions and hate speech, from kids and from grown-ups, every single time that I hear it. I resist in the ways I choose to consume information and perspectives and lives and stories. And I resist in the ways I choose to radically love and accept my students for exactly who they are and the full selves that they bring into my classroom.
And is this enough? Probably not. It will never feel like enough. But it is something. And it is better than the alternative of simply giving up. So who I am now, who I am as a teacher, it is changing and it is adjusting and that adjustment has been really hard. I have profoundly felt the loss of something that I used to know. But I am also going to keep figuring it out because our kids deserve it and this world needs it. So that is where I am. That is where we are.