Festschrift: A Tribute To Dr. William Hordern
December 4, 2025 Leave a comment

Festschrift: A Tribute To Dr. William Hordern
Edited by: Walter Freitag
Publisher: University of Saskatchewan, paperback, 270 pages, including a Greeting, Foreword, William Hordern: Curriculum Vitae, Roster of Institutional Sponsors, Roll of Congratulators, Contributors to the Festschrift, Footnotes, Publications of William Hordern, and an Index
Reviewed by Rev. Garth Wehrfritz-Hanson
I am very grateful to have been privileged to study under the Rev. Dr. William Hordern. Dr. Hordern was a world-renowned theologian, and an excellent professor. He was the teaching assistant for Reinhold Niebuhr and Paul Tillich at Union Theological Seminary, in New York City. He was a professor at the Quaker school, Swarthmore College, in Pennsylvania, and at Garrett Theological Seminary, a Methodist seminary in Evanston, Illinois. From 1966-1985, he served as President of Lutheran Theological Seminary, after the merger of Lutheran College and Seminary and Luther Seminary, in Saskatoon. He also served as a pastor in 3 congregations. The institutional list of sponsors and festschrift contributors affirm that Dr. Hordern was highly respected ecumenically, among a wide variety of denominations.
The Main Body of this volume consists of Part One Studies in Systematics/Ethics, and Part Two Biblical/Historical Studies. Part One has the following 10 essays: Perspective by Dr. Hordern’s wife, Marjorie Hordern, The Question of God and the Trinity by Carl Braaten, Karl Barth Juergen Moltmann and the Theopaschite Revolution by Ronald Goetz, Narrative Theology: Translation or Transformation? By Millard Erickson, Black Theology: It’s Origin, Method and Relation to Third World Theologies by James Cone who was William Hordern’s student, An Update on Liberation Theology in the Canadian Context by Benjamin Smillie, Lubricating the Camel: Clement of Alexandria on Wealth and the Wealthy by Walter Wagner, Realism and Freedom Within a Penitentiary by Gary Watts who was William Hordern’s student, Luther’s Attitude Towards Poverty: Theology and Social Reform by Richard Hordern who is William Hordern’s son and a professor at Luther College, Regina, Is the Emperor Naked?: Religions and Religion in Theological Education by Roland Miller.
Part Two has the following 8 essays: Righteousness as Relationship by Adrian Leske, Luther in the Thought of Bultmann by Walter Freitag, The Courage of Faith at the Eucharist According to Martin Luther by Egil Grislis, Martin Luther in the Writings of Eugen Rosenstock-Huessy, by Eugene Tate, Printing and the Reformation by George Forell, Henry Melchior Muhlenburg’s Canadian Connections by Helmut Lehmann, Canada’s Lutherans in a Mediating Role? by E. Theodore Bachmann, and The Search for Christian Unity by Otto Heick.
Depending on the readers’ preferences and backgrounds—as is the case in a volume like this, some of the essays will be more instructive and inspiring than others.
In this review, I shall briefly highlight one essay from Part One, and one from Part Two, which hopefully will spark readers of this review to read this volume themselves.
Richard Hordern, in his essay, begins by stating that: “Luther’s teachings on poverty and wealth are at the core of his theological program” (p. 94). In the Middle Ages, poverty was understood by the Roman Catholic Church as a spiritual blessing and a virtue for both those in monastery who took a vow of poverty, and for poor laity, who were given alms, which were viewed as good works. Therefore, there was no need to end poverty, nor to view it as an injustice or “an injury to the human spirit” (p. 94).
Luther the monk didn’t see poverty as a spiritual blessing. Rather, he saw it as a hypocrisy among the monks—for they claimed to be poor but lived in comfort and idleness, since the commonfolk paid for the monks’ “poverty.”
Several of Luther’s Ninety-Five Theses of 1517 critiqued how the church burdened and exploited the common and poor people with indulgences, for example, in thesis 43, Luther wrote: “Christians are to be taught that [s]he who gives to the poor or lends to the needy does a better deed than [s]he who buys indulgences.” (Luther’s Works 31:29). In Luther’s response to Johann Eck, Hordern concludes that according to Luther: “We are not called to a virtue of poverty: we are called to abolish poverty” (p. 98).
For Luther, theological reform should also involve economic reform for the poor—so in his appeal To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation, he suggested the creation of a “common chest” to provide for the poor.
Luther was opposed to the early form of capitalism, he criticized high mark-up costs for a product: “What else does this mean but this: I care nothing about my neighbour; so long as I have my profit and satisfy my greed….” (Luther, Trade and Usury, p. 239).
Against monasticism and Anabaptism: “Luther argued that Christians should not hesitate to use the material goods that God has given in trust for the neighbour, provided we have no more than we actually need to conduct our affairs in life” (p. 101).
Luther’s “theology of the cross” is rooted in the Incarnation, hence in life’s realities rather than abstract thought. The “theology of the cross” is revealed: “through human weakness, suffering, humility, oppression, and poverty that we find God and truly understand Christ and the nature of Christ’s salvation through the cross” (p. 103).
Every Christian justified by God’s grace through Jesus is called to respond by loving one’s neighbour, especially the neighbour in need, for Christ meets us in the neighbour.
Otto W. Heick, in his essay, starts by stating: “Luther had no intention of destroying the unity of Western Christianity” (p. 216). Luther did not want his supporters to call themselves after his name. The most important marks of the Church for Luther are the Word and the sacraments. He, on occasion, also added the keys, ministry, prayer, suffering, and the influence of the Word in peoples’ lives as marks of the Church.
Professor Heick points out that in Germany during the Reformation the princes and magistrates play an important role. “The Augsburg Confession, for example, was signed by seven princes and the civil authorities of the cities of Nuremberg and Reutlingen” (p. 217). It was similar in Denmark and Norway, where King Christian III imprisoned and deposed the Catholic bishops and confiscated their estates, and then paid the salaries of evangelical clergy. In Sweden, King Gustavus Vasa had the Church directly place under his authority, and a proclamation stated that Sweden was “an Evangelical Lutheran nation.”
Heick provides a survey of how Lutherans have understood and defined ministry and ordination—there were, and still are differing views. For example, is the ministerial office only a spiritual fellowship or is it a combination of a spiritual fellowship and a divine institution? There was Heinrich Hansen, in Germany, who lead the Hochkirchliche Vereiningung (High Church Association), and: “published a set of Ninety-Five Theses in commemoration of the fourth centennial of the Reformation” (p. 219). There was Danish theologian, hymn writer, and bishop without a diocese, Nicholai F.S. Grundtvig, who believed that: “The living Word has priority over the written Word for the Gospel was spread by the living word of the Apostles and the Church independent of the written Word” (p. 219).
Professor Heick, writing prior to the merger of the Lutheran Church in America Canada Section, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church of Canada into the Evangelical Lutheran Church In Canada in 1986, has a brief commentary on the issues that caused the Missouri Synod to refuse to join the merger. Heick also provides a short history of the various Lutheran organisations that eventually resulted in the formation of the Lutheran World Federation. He highlights when and where the LWF assemblies met, as well as their themes. The title, Lutheran World Federation was adopted at Lund, Sweden in 1947.
Under the section “Lutherans and Catholics in Dialogue,” Heick has a brief historical summary of these dialogues on: “the Status of the Nicene Creed as Dogma of the Church (1965), Baptism (1966), The Eucharist as Sacrifice (1966-67), The Eucharist and the Ministry (1968-70), the Primacy of the Pope (1970-72), Teaching Authority and Infallibility in the Church (concluded in 1978), and Justification by Faith (1983)” (p. 222). He also provides a brief historical summary of the World Council of Churches statement on Baptism, the Eucharist and Ministry. “Both forms, “infant baptism” and “believer’s baptism” embody the primacy of grace and express the response of faith within the believing community” (p. 224).
In his section “The Ecumenical Movement,” Heick states: “Luther was no separatist nor an unyielding dogmatist. In his negotiations with Martin Bucer he was satisfied with saying that the body of Christ is present in the Supper “with” the bread (Wittenberg Concord, 1536, Engl.)” (p. 225). From the 17ththrough to the 19th centuries, Lutherans were involved in colloquies and dialogues leading up to the formation of the World Council of Churches, and since its formation Lutherans have participated in the WCC.
Back in the 17th and 18th centuries: “The clime at the court of Hannover….Linked by marriage to the Catholic house of Hapsburg, the Electress Sophia, friend of Leibnitz, herself of Calvinist training, became in 1713 heir apparent to the throne of Great Britain. Her son, George I, ascended the throne in 1714. Because of his dual reign, he was head of the Lutheran church of Hannover, of the Anglican establishment in England and of the Presbyterian church in Scotland” (Footnote 28., p. 256).
Since through modern technology, we live in a global village and are able to communicate with Christians of every denomination as well as members of every world religion, confessional isolationism is no longer a reality.
In “Publications of William Hordern,” there is a 10 page bibliography of his books and articles.
This volume is still available for purchase online at, for example: https://www.abebooks.com/book-search/isbn/9780888801487/. Theologians, pastors and seminarians will most likely find this a worthwhile read—I rate it as 4.5 out 5. Thank God for the life and legacy of William Hordern!


























Recent Comments