IO (2019), Dir. Johnathan Helpert, 96 mins, Netflix Original
The Great Flood (2025), Dir. Byung-woo Kim, 109 mins, Netflix Original
Last night I watched, by accident really, two Apocalyptic films; both turned out to be pretty poor. The best of intentions, certainly- both seemed to be ambitious, rather than just exploitation nonsense, but neither really worked. The first one I watched, a Netflix original from several years back, IO, got bogged down in existential, environmental anxiety to the detriment of actually moving its plot forward (it was rather like watching paint dry) while the other, a recently-released Korean flick for Netflix, The Great Flood, was actually just the opposite, racing forwards so frantically that it just got sillier and dafter as it sped to its non-ending conclusion. Indeed, that seemed a common issue for both films- bad endings. Not in the sense that either ending was actually bad for either film’s characters, they were fairly optimistic endings, as far as their narratives went, but just bad in the dramatic sense. Both films had endings that left one with that empty, “that’s ninety minutes/two hours of my life I’m not getting back” kind of feeling.; no number of beers can make that feel good.
Both films took liberties with viewer intelligence and any relationship with actual science; in this respect, I suppose they were both more Twilight Zone-like fables, rather than actual realistic dramas. They were possibly dafter than your usual Hollywood blockbuster disaster flick. Its hard to watch something when you’re stuck thinking “no fucking way” regards the central premise.
In IO, a global ecological disaster, pre-film, has rendered the Earth uninhabitable, poison air killing all living things on land and in the sea, other than in isolated pockets (presumably because they are high up, above the cloud level). Prior to the final loss of all human life, one hundred ships fled Earth to gather at a space station orbiting Io, moon of Jupiter. So in the near future (no year is set, but it all looks pretty much present day) one hundred spaceships capable of travelling to the Jovian system, each containing, what, fifty, sixty people (that isn’t ever clear either) and a space station somehow built and orbiting Io, capable of housing and sustaining all those people for an indefinite period, and not only that, but construction facilities there sufficient to build an interstellar spaceship big enough to embark on a ten-year (don’t get me started on that) voyage to a New World at Proxima Centauri, 4.3 light years away. I can imagine Stanley Kubrick or Arthur C Clarke collapsing in a life-threatening fit of the giggles at that lot.
We can’t even get a man (or woman) on the moon, nor Mars, even for a temporary visit, never mind all the way to Jupiter to establish a colony of survivors there. Its bullshit, all for the expediency of some positive alternative to living on the Earth, because the central drama of IO is that Sam (Margaret Qualley), the beautiful young daughter of a dead ecology scientist has endeavoured to ‘fix’ the Earth’s nature problem where tens of thousands of scientists failed, and offer some alternative, a chance for everyone to return to Earth.. Turns out, IO is some teen fantasy disaster flick with the emphasis on boring and being pretentious. I’m too old for this shit.
The Great Flood, meanwhile, starts with a more interesting premise, a sudden, global flood that we soon learn has been caused by an asteroid impact in Antarctica that has melted all the ice and presumably caused a terrible tsunami that threatens all humanity. An Na (Kim Da-mi) lives in on the third floor of an apartment building as the city floods, her floor already taking on water as the film opens, and has to get herself and her infant son Ja In (Kwon Eun-sung) up through the various floors to safety. Just how high can the flood waters rise? Initially its like an Irwin Allen flick, An Na having to circumvent obstacles along the way, but things soon escalate when a hired-gun Hee-jo (Park Hae-soo) from An Na’s employer turns up to assist her with the imperative that she and her child must get to the roof where a company helicopter will be waiting to take them to safety. There are references to An Na’s husband, who died in a car accident when it somehow crashed into a river or lake- more allusions to water and drowning, and some science experiment in AI at An Na’s workplace.
What initially seems to be an increasing series of coincidences becomes its own tsunami of revelations that only get dafter- none of this actually real, its all a computer simulation training An Na to reach some satisfactory conclusion, so the film quickly derails viewer expectations (no bad thing in itself) when everything resets and we’re suddenly in Tom Cruise Edge of Tomorrow (2014) territory, with endless iterations of An Na trying, and failing, to rescue her son. Like the Tom Cruise character in Edge of Tomorrow, An Na starts to remember and learn from her previous attempts and failures (she dies a lot) to find a way of succeeding.
What derails the movie, other than general viewer confusion seeing a Irwin Allen-type disaster flick turn into a Matrix/ Edge of Tomorrow mash-up, is the child, Ja In. I’m not blaming the young actor, he was likely only following directions, but he’s unbearable; a stupid, irritating, endlessly whining, capricious child that cannot seem to follow any instructions and sulks and wails endlessly. Its hard to root for a film that has a central narrative intent on saving a child that you just wish would get shot in the head or thrown into the flood water immediately every time he appears onscreen. Children ruin some movies. Never mind humanity, ditch the kid and save the film. And somehow this kid will be the salvation of the human race?
Well, maybe not- and therein lies the films strangely non-conclusive ending and another leap into IO-level scientific implausibility (oh boy, it was one of those nights): .it turns out humanity is extinct and the simulation is being run by a fleet of orbiting space stations above Earth, in order that, once An Na succeeds in certain emotional and goal targets, she and her child can be 3D printed endlessly as artificial humans who are, in the films conclusion, despatched down to Earth to repopulate the planet.
I think sometimes films can be just too overloaded with ideas, and this was one of them. Its always risking audiences switching off when they feel too disorientated with confusing twists and turns that stretch credibility to breaking point. I wonder how many Netflix viewers abandoned this one midway. Ever the trooper, I stuck with this one to the bitter end, but as with IO, felt rather the fool after it was over. It was a disaster movie night, for sure.