As someone who didn’t post anything for the better part of a year, I think I can officially don the moniker of Bad Blogger. I was noticing recently, though, that if I were to finish and post even a fraction of what I have in drafts, I would actually be rather prolific. Just one problem: most of that stuff has the potential to piss people off. It’s not so much that I shy away from controversy or writing things people may disagree with – I have a thick skin – but rather that I know there’s a smart, tactful, eloquent way to convey what I’m thinking and it seems like I just can’t strike a balance between saying what’s on my mind, yet not sounding preachy and self righteous, or smug, or like a total dick. Thus my drafts folder is an ever growing graveyard of partially written posts, abandoned in disgust or frustration. Some such topics are:
- Desert in the IF Community, as in: the state or condition of being worthy, as in character or behavior. Synonyms: merit, virtue, worth.
There’s a tendency in the IF community to rail against the unfairness of infertility, which is understandable and human. But bloggers always lose me when they bring up the friend/cousin/neighbor who is unemployed/on drugs/a terrible human being and has six kids that they don’t deserve. Deep, deep in my heart and bones – while I know that some people who have children are awful parents and others who can’t have them would be amazing parents, and that this is a shitty and sad state of affairs – I do not believe that a pregnancy or a baby is something one can deserve. Because who is keeping that tally and what are the criteria? Infinite patience? A certain (large) amount in the bank? A big house? We’re all going fall short in one area or another. Even in my saddest, most bitter pregnancy announcement moments, I never thought I deserved to have a baby whilst the other woman didn’t. This isn’t because I’m some great person (believe me, I am not) but because that kind of thinking just doesn’t make sense to my mind. I certainly wished it was me instead of the other woman, thought terrible and uncharitable thoughts about friends and family members, cried and raged like a petulant child… but that was more “wah wah woe is me” than an actual indictment of the unfairness of the Universe. Trite as it sounds, my default answer to such things is, who ever said life was fair? Because really, it’s not. Wanting something, working your ass off to get it and doing all the right stuff may tip the odds in your favor, but is still no guarantee that you’ll get your heart’s desire. There’s no such thing as fairness outside of organized sports, there’s just the shit that happens.
Why I can’t write about it:
Because every time I do, I slip down the slope into religion (because I know exactly “Who” a lot of people believe is keeping the tally of deserts) and then I’m in a whole other, terrible zone I don’t want to be in. You can’t argue faith and I’m not interested in trying, but someone could easily go there and then knowing me I’d have to respond and bam, blog war. So, no.
- Excessive breastfeeding praise is damaging to women
I think the excessive praise for women who go to the ends of the earth to breastfeed – from the simple herbs, teas, oats, cookies or beers, to pumping unto misery, and finally to non-FDA approved drugs from overseas – is just the disguised flip side of full on formula shaming and a way for some women to feel superior, rather than an empowering movement that encourages women to trust our bodies to nourish our children. Every time I read a post from a woman who sounds exhausted and sad because breastfeeding is so hard, every single reply seems to be something like “Ifyouneedtouseformulathatstotallyfinebecauseallthatmattersisthatyourbabyeats BUT YOU ARE SO AMAZING FOR DOING ALL THIS YOU ARE A MAMMARY WARRIOR!!!!!!!” Because in the little corner of Blog World I inhabit, we’re mostly on the liberal end of the spectrum, so people feel they have to start with giving lip service to the idea that formula is totally fine of course, because hey, we don’t judge other people’s choices! We are liberal and accepting! But when you read between the lines, the message is pretty clear: Do Everything You Possibly Can to Breastfeed No Matter What. If you do so and it doesn’t work out, we will congratulate you for your hard work, shake our heads in pity and say, “Well at least formula exists” and accept you, poor unfortunate soul, into our midst. If you simply choose not to breastfeed (the horror), we will politely avert our eyes and cough daintily, but not say much, all the while knowing that you have chosen to deprive your baby of something incredibly important because you are selfish cow, and we are better. The whole thing just burns me up. How about saying to a new mother with supply issues who is sad, overwhelmed, in pain and at her wits’ end, “You’ve tried every trick in the book, don’t feel like you have to order sketchy drugs off the internet; give your baby all the breast milk you can and supplement with formula. He’ll still get the benefits of being breastfed as well as a happy parent. Babies not only survive on formula, they thrive, just like on breast milk.” Maybe then we would actually have a community of support and choice, rather than just the appearance of one.
Why I can’t write about it:
Talk about a hot button issue. I haven’t posted this post for pretty obvious reasons. People get cah-razy over breastfeeding. The drama is real.
I actually had to put my money where my mouth was on this one. I’ve always felt this way, but when I went back to work after 4 months and couldn’t keep up with Mac, even pumping 3x a day, I was faced with the reality of giving my exclusively breastfed baby formula. It should have been easy, because I think formula is a perfectly good source of food for a baby, but it wasn’t. I cried, I had feelings of failure, I pumped more, I consumed oats and raspberry leaf tea and Mother’s Milk Plus and beer… I did all the things. And then I sat down and had a good think about why I was so resistant to giving my son formula if I thought formula was ok? Was it just ok for other babies, but not mine, because in reality I thought formula was substandard and only breast milk was actually good? Well, yeah, kinda sorta, but not because I actually believed that. I realized that I was caught up in the undercurrent of approval and superiority that surrounds breastfeeding, especially where I live in NYC (An aside: a good friend of mine who lives in a well-to-do hippie crunchy area of Brooklyn had a woman in her moms group confide that she was secretly supplementing her daughter with formula, but please not to tell the others. That’s some powerful shame right there.) What I was feeling was in part just run of the mill mother guilt for not being willing to do ANYTHING and EVERYTHING to provide my kid with the Gold Standard of nutrition, but also a sneakier feeling, one I liken to someone trying to make you feel bad about wearing inexpensive shoes or driving the “wrong” kind of car – basically make you feel less than. No longer being an exclusive breastfeeder meant no longer being part of the in-crowd on the “right” side of the all important breastfeeding issue. So I thought about it, and then I gave my son some formula, and he is healthy, happy and the most wonderful kid I know.
- If Facebook makes you feel bad, stop using Facebook
This is something that utterly baffles me. I don’t have FB – never have, and I don’t quite get the appeal – but if it’s something you enjoy then great, “Like” stuff in good health. But it seems to me that no one actually enjoys Facebook. From studies and articles like this one, to the creation of new terms like FOMO, to the anecdotal evidence of my own friends bitching, to the fact that a new “taking a break from FB” post appears in my reader multiple times per week, Facebook seems like a scourge upon the internet. But when I mention this radical option to whining friends, I invariably get some version of, “Oh, but it’s how I keep in touch with all my friends/family/people I went to kindergarten with and haven’t seen since!” No. Rejected. It is 2016 and there are so many ways to keep in touch with the important people in your life. SO MANY! Email, Skype, Facetime, countless chat and photosharing apps – it’s harder to be out of touch than in touch these days. And it’s probably those randoms from elementary school who are making you the most sad, since with real friends you might actually know about their rocky marriage, or kid’s behavior problems at school, or trouble getting pregnant, rather than just their perfectly manicured Facebook persona. Either trim the fat with extreme prejudice down to real friends and the family you actually like (hint: No one has 200 real friends. Nope, not 100 either), or better yet, just cancel it and take back your (online) life. Barring that, stop complaining about something you have 100% complete control over, it’s silly.
Why I can’t write about it:
This one’s on me. I find the Facebook-addiction phenomenon so mystifying and irritating that I can’t write about it in any kind of diplomatic way. The above was my best attempt and probably offensive to plenty of people. Eh.
There are more, of course – I have no shortage of opinions – but I think I’ll stop there and wait for the virtual torches and pitchforks to come a-callin’.