This issue is interesting because when you ask someone this question, you will basically find out what their stance is on downloading in general. You will find out whether that person thinks it’s okay to download music, movies, etc. I think that the artist has the right to decide whether he or she wants to share what they have just created. If someone wants to share a short movie they just made because they believe it helps society in general to share it, then why not? Of course, I would also understand if an artist just wants to be private and discreet, and not share anything.
My personal stance is that I am in favor of downloading. If people are so worried about their idea’s getting stolen, then they do not grasp the idea of artistic evolution. Basically, it is almost impossible for someone not to steal from you creatively, intellectually, or what not, in some shape or form at some point in your life. That is just the way things are. You also have the right to hear or see an idea that might inspire you to create something great as well. It’s a double-edged sword. But an awesome double-edged sword.
To elaborate more on what I think about downloading, let me a share a track that I produced. This is trance music. Basically, it’s mixing melodies and rythms in a 4/4 time signature. I feel like you can take it to a new level with chord progressions and constructing powerful build-ups. As well as having to compose these ideas if you are writing from scratch. One must have some knowledge of music theory and understand how to create melodies. To have some sort of structure to it, as well as to add excitement, you add a new element every 8 bars. It is a branch of EDM.
I made this on a macbook air.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/552395
Now, it has 1,014 plays and 67 downloads. You could look at it and say, well that’s 67 dollars I could have made if I was selling it on iTunes. But I don’t see it that way. They would never have heard the song if I hadn’t shared it, because I’m not famous yet. So I would rather let people hear it first and get some feedback on it, instead of withholding it from someone who might really like it. It’s free publicity. And even if someone did steal it from you and pass it as their own, you have the original file and would be able to win any lawsuit. So yeah, I’m all about sharing. Sharing is caring.
That’s basically how I feel about software piracy. You almost have to expect that people are going to steal and copy. That is just how it is. People use torrents all the time. If someone is skilful enough to turn a demo into the full program, or has the know how to download really well, then you won’t be able to stop them. It is almost like hacking and sort of a skill in some way. If the product is licensed then that company will still make money. People will still buy it from the stores. A few computer guys will be able to obtain it for free, but I think that is sort of expected already. They could impose sanctions or be strict but it is not really intimidating. That warning that comes on before every movie doesn’t scare anyone and people have been copying movies from beta, to vhs, to dvd, and so on for decades. So I don’t really blame someone who downloads something if it does cost them 2 months salary. People will always try to look for the best deal. It doesn’t mean that if they did have the money they wouldn’t buy it, because they probably would. It just all depends sometimes. This is just the evolution of IT at work.