From Mother I learned a few things including work ethic, frugality and cynicism.
We are a large family who regularly attended the local Methodist church. We grew up with the usual mythology of our society: Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy.
I think perhaps Santa was the first one to go. One of my older brothers put me in the picture. ‘Don’t believe that rubbish. They only say that to get you to be good. It’s our parents who give us the presents.’
‘You mean there isn’t really an old guy who travels all over the world in his sleigh in one night delivering toys to all good children? But I’ve seen him. I’ve seen him at the store. He comes to our Sunday School Christmas party.’
‘Nah, stupid. That’s just someone dressed up. That was Mr D at the Sunday School party.’
‘Oh.’
‘But don’t tell ’em ya know. Pretend you still believe. Otherwise they might not give you anything.’
I was good at keeping secrets. In my family I found the best way to stay out of trouble was to be invisible.
So, Christmas Eve I still went to bed early and in the morning there were still toys in the pillow case. It took quite a few years before mother stopped using this as a control mechanism—’Now you be a good boy or Santa won’t come.’
The Easter Bunny was used in much the same way. And the Tooth Fairy too. Cripes, isn’t it enough that I lost a tooth? Do I actually have to be good as well to get a few lousy pennies? Sooner or later my older siblings set me straight.
There was one more myth being used in our family as a means of control. I didn’t need an older sibling to help me figure this one. I could do it myself. At the age of eight I relegated God, Heaven and Hell to the control-mechanism basket.
This one was too big to talk about with my siblings. Mother wielded a pretty mean strap. I wasn’t prepared to risk her finding out. Keep silent. Stay invisible. Which meant, of course, I had to continue going to Sunday School every week. I wasn’t a very good student. I feel sorry for those teachers having to put up with this little atheist. Though, of course, they didn’t know what was behind his lack of interest.
Somehow, despite this I was taking in all that stuff. I can still recite many passages from the King James Bible and I’m no longer a young man. I think that much of the moral stuff was worthwhile. It’s stuck and I’ve lived by it. And even the stuff that I challenge on an intellectual level, it’s much harder to challenge in practice. I remember many of the stories too. I enjoyed them just as I did the fairy stories from my childhood.
At the age of 12 I was asking my Sunday School teacher questions like, ‘If Jesus and God are one, why did he have to pray to God?’ I could answer that now but the best my teacher could do was ‘There are some things you have to accept you can’t understand.’
‘Yeah,’ this cynical kid thought (but didn’t say) ‘there are some things that you don’t understand. That’s why you can’t answer me.’
At around that time I found a way out of going to Sunday School. Even though Sunday was the Sabbath, it seemed in our family the work ethic was stronger. I could go caddying at the golf course and earn myself some pocket money. I was expected to go to the evening church service instead. I was still seen to be worshipping the Lord.
Church was easier. It wasn’t so interactive. I could drift off in a world of my own. Just had to remember to stand up for the hymns.
I also learned that I could sometimes get away with being forgetful. Remember, I was very good at remaining invisible. Sometimes I would be noticed. ‘Joe. Quick. Hurry up and get ready for church.’
‘Oh, look. It’s seven o’clock already. I won’t make it. Too bad.’ I’m sure I looked appropriately disappointed.
Mother had stopped going to church herself some years before. Like I said we are a big family. Father had no particular skills nor was he a physically strong man. Work wasn’t always easy to come by. When he found a job serving beer at the golf club some of the ladies at the church snubbed Mother. She was pretty pissed off by this. She felt God wouldn’t judge someone who was prepared to work to feed their children even if the church ladies did. She still kept up her duties on the flower roster and of course attended at Easter and Christmas. When it was her turn to decorate the church she’d go down in the morning and set up the flowers and return for the evening service so she could bring them home again after the service. Father had never been a regular church attender, just the special occasions, but he felt it was important for us to be given a good Christian upbringing.
At one stage I started going to the Plymouth Brethren church that had opened a few hundred yards from our place in the opposite direction to our church. Why did I go there? It was closer. Why walk the best part of a mile when you could get away with a much shorter walk?
On my first night no one really noticed me. I slipped out after the service and back home. ‘Why are you home so early?’ Father asked.
‘I went to the other church.’ Father didn’t object. So long as I went to church. (But of course, not the Catholics which was also close.)
On my second night one of the brethren said hello and asked my name. ‘Trusting in the Lord, Joe?’ he went on.
I was gutless. After so many beatings from Mother there was no way I could reveal to this stranger who I really was. ‘Yes.’ I answered feebly.
After that I was accepted by the Brethren. They were very friendly. They didn’t know Father’s work history and perhaps it wouldn’t have mattered to them if they did. There was a bonus too. There were two pretty girls I’d noticed at my high school who attended this church. I even got to visit the home of one of them. I was an extremely shy kid but we became friends at a fairly superficial level.
Father was the one who would tend to remember that I should be going to church. Perhaps Mother had given up on me a few years before or perhaps as part of her displeasure with the other women she gave up on the church. One night when Mother was doing the flower duties I decided it was time to confront Father. I would never had done this if Mother was home but Father didn’t have her cruel streak. He was an easier target.
‘Shouldn’t you be getting ready for church?’ he asked.
‘I’m not going.’
‘What do you mean? Why not?’
‘I don’t believe what they teach.’
‘Well, you can go to the other church. I don’t mind.’
‘I don’t believe them either.’
‘What do you mean you don’t believe?’
‘I don’t believe in God.’
We had a long man to man discussion. Perhaps our first.
‘So, if God doesn’t exist where do we come from?’
‘Where did God come from?’
‘Well, it had to start somewhere.’
‘Then why not with us?’
He couldn’t answer that one. Stumped by a 14-year-old kid.
I learned to admire Father on that night. ‘OK. I’ll never make you go to church again. But don’t ever tell Mother. It would break her heart.’
Yeah. And she’d set about breaking me too.
For the first time in my life, I felt I’d been treated with respect. I love Father for that.