I’ve lived in California for almost three years. I’ve been summoned twice for the noble task of jury duty. The first time, I asked to be excused because the timing was completely inconvenient. The second time, I went in.
It was late November. Everyone told me the likelihood of actually being chosen was low. I figured I’d just get out of work for a day, hang out at the Oakland courthouse, and hopefully get some reading done. Right?
After watching an incredibly lame dvd about how wonderful jury duty is, my name was called. I was herded with 125 other potential jurors to the courtroom. The judge explained that this was a murder trial. He wanted us to fill out a questionnaire and then return two days later. Ok… interesting. So I sat in the jury room filling out 25 pages about my beliefs and ties to the legal system.
Two days later, we all returned. By random, they called up 12 people to sit in the jury box. They handed the first juror a microphone and started asking questions about their paperwork. I was frozen. Seriously? They are going to have us explain ourselves in front of a hundred people? I started sweating. What did I write again? Was it stupid? Incorrect? How does my hair look?
One by one, the lawyers dismissed jurors and called up new ones for questioning. It was obvious the people who wanted out. It was obvious the people who wanted in. I couldn’t figure out the rhyme or reason as to who they were keeping and dismissing. Finally, on the second day, they called up Janelle Stanelle.
I stammered through questions about my work, my volunteer roles, my husband’s job, my past speeding tickets, my name and why it rhymes… It was painful, but it ended. Now all I had to do was wait until they dismissed me like all the other jurors before me. Two days passed, dozens more questioned, and I remained. That’s how I became juror number 3.
For the two weeks to follow, instead of heading to work in Berkeley, I got on the subway to downtown Oakland. Every day, I walked through a metal detector, took a private elevator to a secured floor, said hello to our armed guard, and took a seat in a bulletproof locked room. My days were filled with reviewing evidence, listening to witnesses, and learning about the differences between 1st and 2nd degree murder and manslaughter.
I wish I could explain all of the details related to the trial. The truth is, there is gang activity involved and I’m happy to keep some anonymity. Somehow I ended up as the foreman and was tasked with “leading” the other jurors in the deliberation process. Three days of discussion and we came to our conclusion.
As we filed back into the courtroom, we gave our verdict. I stared straight ahead and barely glanced at the defendant, who was surrounded with police officers. Families were crying, but somehow the room was absolutely silent. We walked back up to our jury room, gathered our items, and headed on our way.
I guess I tell this story, because I just learned of the defendant’s punishment. The judge sentenced him to 60 years to life in prison. That sits really strangely with me. He committed the crime, that’s not a question. But to know that someone is spending their life in jail because of something you did is a weird feeling. I don’t feel guilty, but I don’ t feel guiltless. I just am sitting in the fact that I helped do this. What is justice? What is the justice that God calls us to? And how do we love both mercy and justice?