I tried to introduce someone to BDSM once.
We were partners on-and-off for three years. I convinced him, after many months, to experiment with tying me up, or spanking me. But I was impatient, always pushing him further, needing more, feeling abandoned and unsatisfied when he couldn’t meet those needs. Basically, I fucked him up so severely in regard to sex I’m surprised he still talks to me.
So you’ll understand if I’m wary of trying again. But for the sake of everyone intrigued by Fifty Shades, but unsure of themselves, it’s a little selfish to keep all my experience to myself.
Nature vs. nurture is a constant battle, but some things are simply born into people: you’re born gay, you’re a natural athlete, or maybe, like me, you’re innately Submissive. And I don’t mean light-bondage-and-some-spanking submissive, or even let’s-go-to-a-dungeon-once-a-month submissive, but a hard-core, 24/7, whip-me-till-I-scream, need-it-to-feel-human Sub.
This is hard to understand for almost anyone, the same way it is hard for me to understand a lense of pleasure that doesn’t include pain, or how sex can lack a power dynamic (and how that would be erotic?). And believe me, I’ve spent my entire life trying to reconcile those desires with a self who is passionate, strong-willed, and extremely feminist. I’ve spent my life trying to remove the shame like a surgeon so I can come to you clean and open.
Because at the heart of BDSM and its community is acceptance. Until you can accept people as they are, flaws and fetishes, desires and fears, then you have no place with us.
In fact, over the years I’ve tried explaining the BDSM community to an array of strangers and friends, and I’m always surprised at how difficult it is. The mystique and eroticism of our lives has been wildly misrepresented. With dramatised, inauthentic splashes like Fifty Shades, SVU episodes, political scandals, and even regular porn, that’s not so much surprising as it is deeply frustrating. So today I’d like to pull the curtain open and show you what it’s really like…
Let’s start with the most basic of basics:
B – D – S – M
These letters stand for six distinct words:
B&D: Bondage & Discipline
D/s: Dominant/submissive
S&M: Sadism / Masochism
Classic BDSM will often include some if not all of these aspects, and usually necessitates some type of power exchange. In classic BDSM, parties with power are the Dominants and go by Dom, Top, Master, Sir/Mistress, etc. A Switch is someone who straddles the line by enjoying both roles. And submissives are known as subs, pets, slaves, littles, or any number of other humiliating names. And yes, capitalizing one and not the other is purposeful and common.
BDSM as a subculture, however, umbrellas all non-normative sexuality, and really anyone is welcome, from the guy who likes to be walked on to the guy who crossdresses every once and awhile. Classic BDSM aside, whatever you’re into – infantilism, furries, vorp… – kinksters will put aside judgement and welcome you into the club.
BDSM events are pieces of a large network called the Scene: “I’ve been active on the Scene for about four years”; “Have you been to any Scene parties lately?” Events that occur on the Scene include anything from private gangbangs, swingers parties, and wax demonstrations to sensuality and tantra circles, rope lessons, toy releases, and weekly munches for sub-groups to meet and socialize. It’s a vast network of individuals with their unique orientations, gender expressions, power dynamics, relationships, nationalities, socioeconomic statuses, kinks…
I get questions like “is everyone bi?” and “you must have a lot of orgies.” So let me make this clear: Kinksters Are People. We have jobs, we pay car insurance, we fret over our new haircut, and we try to find time to visit that new dungeon on Delancey. Kinksters are not having brutal, crazy sex all day. Orgies are exceptionally hard to organize (UGH trust me). We pay for the parties we attend. It’s not a montage of flashing lights, thrumming bass, writhing bodies, and that one chick moaning on a cross.
Well, okay. Sometimes it is. But we’ll get to that.
Events that permit sexual or kinky activities are termed Play Parties. A few notes about play party code of conduct: First, and most important, is express verbal consent. Ask before you touch anyone aside from yourself. If the answer is no, don’t take it personally, or demand a reason, simply back off. “No” is a complete sentence, after all.
Second, as a voyeur, how close you stand to any activity should be indirectly proportional to how intense the scene is. For a couple making out, the other end of the couch is a fair vantage point. When it’s sweaty, personal fucking, somewhere across the room is more appropriate. Most importantly, don’t interrupt, especially in the midst of a BDSM scene.
In this context, the word “scene” also represents a situation that plays out between two or more individuals at a play party. A scene has three phases. First, all parties involved negotiate what will occur in the scene, what desires overlap. Second, the scene plays out – importantly, all parties check in with each other during the process. Afterward, there is Aftercare, where the submissive(s) is comforted and catered to, or a Debriefing, where everyone talks about what went down and how they liked it, or both.
But this is all starting to sound like I’m speaking legaleze. So, how would you like a story?
My first visit to Paddles, a popular dungeon in lower Manhattan, came after so many years of longing, I was surprised at how nervous I was. Hadn’t this been the goal, the dream all along? Sure, I certainly wouldn’t participate tonight, but I’ve been reading into BDSM since I was 13. It’s not like this place could surprise me.
But I suppose that didn’t matter, because I was terrified. The thrill of being inside, corsets everywhere, toys adorning the walls, the smell of leather rich and euphoric, and still I couldn’t strike up the nerve to strike up a conversation. I sat in a wing-backed chair and watched someone prepare for a suspension scene.
Paddles is a no-sex-no-booze dungeon. There’s a bar for soda, a stage for demos, and enough nooks and crannies to make an english muffin jealous. Some corners are very cramped, and it’s not exactly the cleanest of clubs, but Paddles is closer to what I always imagined dungeons would be like than anywhere else I’ve been to.
Eventually, because I am young and beautiful and probably reek of slavery, a man came over and introduced himself. He was Tomas, he was blonde and Australian and a complete gentleman. He didn’t seem to mind my stuttering responses, or nervous fidgeting. After about a half an hour, when we’d gotten to know one another and both revealed our personal kinks, he asked if I’d be interested in negotiating a scene with him surrounding a spanking.
I remember having difficulty breathing, and hearing sirens go off in my head. I wanted it. I didn’t want it. I’d decided not to participate tonight. Would it be alright to break that rule?
So I cut myself some slack and asked if I could have a few minutes to think about it. I went to the restroom, played a game of solitaire on my phone, rebalanced myself, and asked the toughest question there is: Why Not?
“Why not” is very easily answered by fear. But when you can recognize that fear, you can push it aside. Why not? I rejoined Tomas and, haltingly, told him what I was looking for. He asked for a few minutes to prep.
By all accounts, asking for what I want as a submissive is the most difficult part. It requires that I actively and willingly humiliate, debase, and expose myself….while I’m still in charge of my faculties. Once the scene is in play, none of those things matter, but up to that edge, it can be very stressful and confusing.
But I’d made my decision. The terms for the scene were clear, and very basic: spanking (instruments permitted) sensation play, light bondage. Tomas allowed me to choose between being bent over a bench in an occupied room, or strung up inside a caged alcove. I am relatively shy. I chose the latter.
He went very slowly with me, warming me up so gently the first few hits didn’t even register. My eyes closed out of instinct, hands gripping my loose restraints. He had me spread my legs, and the slaps came harder, resonating into my chest like a second heartbeat. I let go, and entered subspace.
Subspace is the term submissives use to describe…well, it’s hard to describe. It’s a headspace where time, space, reality, all melt away; nothing exists except the sensations, floating on a comforting wave of submission. Some subs struggle to ascend to subspace, while others find it more easily, and you can experience it at many different levels.
Personally, subspace is only ever a forceful word away, where I can forget who I am, that I’m even human, and succumb completely to my Top’s desires. I become fluid, obedient, and perfectly at peace.
Some uncounted time later he paused, leaned in close, asked if we were Green. In BDSM, safe words are paramount, and when in doubt people tend to go with the classics: “Red” for a Full Stop, “Yellow” to pause or protest something specific, and “Green” to indicate continued consent. Then he asked if I wanted more.
In subspace, human words are a far-off luxury, but after a few tries I was able to respond with a question of my own. “May I take off my dress?” If I wasn’t going to let myself get truly vulnerable, what was the point?
When I was disrobed and rebound, my eyes flickered open for a moment, and I noticed for the first time that the back wall of this cage was mirrored. I looked at myself, spread eagle, clad only in my underwear for this man I had met an hour ago and felt a rush of arousal and serenity. This was where I belonged. Hungry eyes peered at me from behind the cage bars. I remember the surge of pride at being watched like this, shameless and beautiful.
And then he started in again, firmer, the pain rising full and supple and more to my taste. My moaning got louder, I’m sure. I felt him come up behind me, felt his erection through his pants, loved knowing that this was as pleasurable for him as it was for me. And then he started in with the hairbrush.
Tomas dragged the scratchy tips across my back first, informing me of what was to come and sending incomprehensible shivers through my body. He spanked me with the bristles, and on my heated skin it stung in the most delirious way. I was floating, completely out of my mind, as the scene hit a crescendo. The flat side of the brush made such a satisfying thud noise as it met my skin, and I panted and struggled, and he told me I was going to get 50 more.
They got worse and worse, and I struggled and cried out until suddenly, it stopped. He caressed my skin, held me in place while I sagged, consumed by my own submission. Whether or not I wanted it to go on, the scene was over, a closed circuit, no strings attached.
He unbound me slowly, comforting, letting me float back to earth, then sat me down and got me a glass of water. We talked about the scene and I thanked him, sincerely. Then I redressed, kissed his cheek, and left. Two blocks down I stopped on the lawn of a mental hospital and allowed myself a clove cigarette to celebrate.
Because these events are worth celebrating. For those of us who thrive on the fulfillment of our kinky desires, there is a languor, joy, and ensuing sense of purpose that will buoy us for days after an experience like this. I couldn’t get enough of looking at my bruises in the mirror, the way they mottled and changed color, spiking into agony when I pressed one. The sense of elation is hard to relate.
But if you do – relate, I mean – let me know. I’ve been studying kink, sex, consent, alternate relationship styles, and queer issues to some degree or other for ten years. BDSM’s greatest obstacle, and the only thing getting in the way of your exploring it, is ignorance. No question is too ridiculous, too basic, too specific, too broad. I want them all, the good, the bad, the nasty, and the kinky-as-fuck.
Try me. Questions can be sent to [email protected] (and will be promptly deleted, upon request).
Curious? Let’s get started.
-Persephone