Hello everyone!
I hope you’re all having a lovely 2023 so far. Mine has been mostly filled with work but I’ve found some time here and there for things like baking and of course, crochet.
When I was at a local Joann store recently (not my main one that I usually go to but one close to work), I discovered this tool that I hadn’t seen before–the Susan Bates “Twist + Lock” Interchangeable Crochet Hooks! I had heard of things like this but I wasn’t aware that this brand had released one. And I noticed that it looked like you could have one hook installed in the top and another stored in the bottom, so you could have two constantly available in the one tool. I was intrigued, and there was a sale for 25% off, so I went for it!
Since I hadn’t heard of this one before, I wanted to share my thoughts with you guys. That way if you’re considering picking it up for yourself (like a couple of you on Instagram mentioned), then you can see the experience of someone else to help decide if it’s right for you!
First of all, the basic details if you don’t want to read all of my ramblings:
- What I bought was the combo that had the handle as well as a 5mm (H) hook and a 5.5mm (I) hook. There were other options to buy a full set of various sizes, or just extra hooks if you have the handle, and it looked like there’s even a yarn cutter available that somehow fits in somewhere!
- Price: the one I bought was $16.49 on sale, regularly $21.99 (this is Joann pricing, other sites/stores will vary)
- First impression: it’s acceptable, honestly. 7.5/10 if I have to rate it on the spot. I have thoughts about how it could be better but would I keep this in a project bag? Yes. Will I buy more sizes? Maybe.
Ok now for my full thoughts in more detail:
How it Feels:
This hook is on the larger side for sure! The big handle is similar to other comfort grip or ergonomic hooks I’ve seen around. With a hook installed and the other stored in the handle it measures about 7.5″ long. Without the other hook stored in the base, that takes it down to 7″ even. Something oddly shaped like this is hard to measure accurately but at what looks like the widest spot in the handle, I measured it at roughly 2.4-2.5″ around. It’s thicker than some of my largest hooks that aren’t specifically ergonomic, but I would say it’s not that different from the feel of something like a Furls Odyssey in terms of diameter and feel in the hand.
If you’re wondering, I’m not shy about the fact that I prefer and honestly kind of love Clover Amour. Like many others, I tried a lot of hooks before settling on those and they’ve been my go-to for years. They’re pricey for basic hooks but I do really enjoy them and have re-bought various sizes as I use them.
So I don’t own many Susan Bates hooks and couldn’t even find one in my craft room to compare although I know they exist around here somewhere. All this was to say I’m not usually a Bates person.
BUT…I chose to keep an open mind here and try these out with the goal of honest feedback. And I didn’t really mind it once I got going! I think it’s pretty comparable to other Bates hooks for use of stitching, like how easily it actually slips through the stitches or picks up the yarn. I didn’t personally love how it worked for that, but I do remember that’s how I feel with any Bates-style hook. I just don’t like the inset style as much and that’s not a fair judgement when, you know, this is a Bates hook that I chose to review. I consider any Bates hook like a B+ for stitching and feel in my hand, and that’s exactly what I felt this one was too.
However, the weight of the longer handle plus the extra hook in the base was slightly hard to ignore. I could definitely feel the added weight as I stitched! I’m sure you’d get used to this as you worked with it, and I can’t say how it feels with the yarn cutter instead, but I was slightly put off by this sensation.
Summary of the feel: Meh, it’s alright, but that’s more due to it being a Bates hook. 8 out of 10 “points” for this.
How it Looks:
At first look, a little silly.
I pulled it out of the package and my only thought was “okay, I’m not sure what I expected”. It’s the two hooks and a big plastic handle.
But honestly, it’s more of a novelty and a tool than anything. I don’t think anyone looks at these sets and thinks it’s absolutely gorgeous and would be a perfect addition to their coffee table display of hooks. They look at it and think how useful it would be to have two sizes in one always available in their purse or project bag. So I’m not going to fault it for that. Boring but fine.
Although I do have a complaint about my hook, though.
I used it for about twenty minutes to work up a swatch this afternoon for the purpose of this review, and some kind of coating on the rubber is peeling already! When it came out of the box I noticed a rough surface in that area of the handle but it wouldn’t affect the comfort of the hook so I didn’t mind it. Seems like I might have gotten a bit of a dud if it’s peeling. (Note: looking at their site I am far from the only one with this issue and it seems like the company is gathering information on it so that’s awesome!)
I’ll continue to use it though, and see if it gets worse or if one bit comes off and then it’s fine.
Looks summary: I would say 8 again but with mine peeling, 6/10. It’s not that pretty to begin with and mine is also damaged I guess.
Ease of Use (interchangeability):
I consider this part a win. This system was so simple to figure out. To be fair, I initially was mildly confused on which end of the hook was the top/bottom (it does seem to matter!) and was trying to put in the hook in the wrong way, and thought the product was dumb. Then I realized with the storage option on the base I might be trying the wrong side, flipped it around…and it was easy as pie.
It’s really simple to use the interchangeable function, in my experience. It’s spring-loaded on the inside but just takes some mild pressure and a quick twist to lock in the hook on the top. I can’t see it coming loose very easily either since you would need to both push down and twist in the right direction to remove it.
The base is a similar motion but you just insert it the other way, so the hook is stored inside and the gray base sticks out at the bottom.
I really can’t think of any way I’d improve this function. I first wished that the stored one went further inside and didn’t stick out as much, but then it might be more difficult to take out and I bet they had to find the sweet spot to have enough room to grip it.
Summary of this switching function: 9.5/10. If they had a more obvious visual difference of which is the top/bottom, I would consider it perfect. (Note: there is a QR code on the box that I assumed would have a helpful video or something but it just leads to the product page.)
Actual Crochet Use:
Here is where this hook did well, in my opinion.
Like I said, I don’t use Bates hooks very often and I mostly keep them around as backup. If I’m traveling with a project I’ll sometimes bring those because if it happens to get lost I’m less heartbroken. That sounds rough but they’re just not my first choice! If I had one in one of these sizes I would have used that for this swatch comparison but instead I used my trusty favorite, my Clover Amour H/5mm hook.
Here’s my two swatches for comparison:
They look pretty much the same visually. I just swatched it up with basic HDC, the first thing that came to mind. I tried my best to keep the same tension both times and did the same row/stitch count. They look identical in size laid on top of each other, and the stitch definition looks the same as well. Below is my actual stitching with this Bates hook if you’re curious.
I’d call this basically the same in stitch results, which is awesome! It means the comfort or the difference in hook style didn’t affect my actual stitching, and I could swap this out if I was in the middle of a project and wanted to bring this set instead of my usual hooks.
Crochet use summary: 10/10, I had no issues with how it stitched up.
Overall Thoughts:
So this was kind of a back-and-forth review. I started it out thinking it was pretty nice and seemed useful, and I didn’t mind it when I used it for swatching. But then I noticed mine was peeling, and if that was a one-off I wasn’t going to care. Sometimes a bad product sneaks through and as long as it doesn’t cause any issues, whatever.
But knowing that many others had the same thing happen, there was something getting through their quality checks or an issue with their actual rubber material. Now they do seem to be helping people out with this and someone was reaching out to those reviewers asking for more information and to have a conversation with them so that’s great. But obviously the best reaction is never going to be as great as avoiding releasing the product with those issues in the first place.
If I add up all of my “scores” I get 8.375/10, which is actually fairly close to the initial score I gave it of an 8! The stitching and the simplicity really helped boost my opinion of it, and I guess the feel in my hand didn’t bother me as much since I’m trying to keep an open mind about a Bates hook. But please look to reviewers who like and regularly use Bates hooks for a better comparison on that front!
I guess I agree with my 8ish scoring. It’s…okay. It’s not the best new thing (not really that new but relatively), it’s not a “gotta have”, but if you like this sort of tool and you want to have two hooks always available in one handle? It’s fine. I wouldn’t buy another handle but I would buy more hook sizes since that’s not the part I had trouble with.
Would I consider it worth twenty bucks? Not really. I can buy two decent hooks for close to that price that are better quality.
But is it worth what I paid, with a sale and a reward voucher? Yes. I think I paid roughly 13-14 bucks for mine between sales and coupons, and it’s worth that.
My parting words are this–if you like these hooks, great! Please share that joy with others and share your positive thoughts and reviews to help balance it with those of us who were not the biggest fan. Everyone is different and we’re not all going to love or hate the same things. Like what you like, and use what you want to use.
I hope you all have a great year and get to stitch up many lovely things! See you next time!
If you’d like to check out my designs, please feel free to look through my Ravelry store! And if you want to see what I’m working on next, follow me on Instagram. I also write monthly crochet pattern reviews over on the EyeLoveKnots blog!