A Willful Woman…

Thoughts about books

Silent Flames by Cate C. Wells

(FYI: This is fourth in a multi-author “dark romance” series. I thought the first one was okay but didn’t bother with the second or third, and that wasn’t an issue at all. They seem to happen pretty much concurrently.)

“Pretty girls are supposed to break like electronic toys–quietly, with no real loss of appeal. We’re not supposed to be pitiful. To make people uncomfortable. We exist for the opposite purpose right?”

The reviews for this book are fascinating. Aside from the inevitable ones saying “no way in hell will I ever read a book with a cheater hero” — which Wells is wisely extremely upfront about, but they’re still pissed at her šŸ˜‚ — most of the negative ones are from people who really wanted to read a very typical book about a cheater hero and how much he suffered and groveled, and they weren’t satisfied. Whereas I thought it took the usual trope and enhanced it in a very satisfying way.

Happily married wife and mother Cora plans to surprise her adoring husband Adrian with a family visit — but she’s the one who’s surprised when she catching him having sex with another woman in his office. That’s hardly the worst of it though. Instead of an explanation and fervent apologies, Adrian reveals that everything she thought she knew about their marriage is a sham. He never loved her, he only married her for children, and he has complete legal control over their custody. And because she signed a pre-nup, he thinks she knew all of this already.

But there’s a lot Adrian doesn’t know about Cora either. Especially that she’s been driven to a breaking point before, and when she breaks, she breaks hard.

The real surprise: this is a romance about two people with severe, unacknowledged trauma, and the destructive things they do because of it. Especially Cora. Cora is a freaking mess. (It’s rare to find a romance heroine with such legitimately severe mental health problems, and I honestly loved that.) But when she stops living a lie and starts letting her crazy out, something else happens: they start to know each other and their relationship becomes real for the first time.

I guess there isn’t a typical “grovel”? I didn’t really notice because I was happy with the reworking of their relationship to become real and honest. And Adrian constantly demonstrates how much he really does care about Cora, which would be my particular dealbreaker in romance.

On the negative side: Uber-powerful billionaire romance, ugh. There’s some old skool Evil Other Woman drama, a bit too much repetition, and a little too much reliance on the idea that Cora despite everything is a perfect mom who would never do anything to hurt her children. Mental health problems don’t work like that, in my experience.

There are also significant emotional changes in both of them that we see only though the pov of the other character, and though it works pretty well, I would have enjoyed seeing their own emotional realizations. Perhaps this is why some readers felt it was lackluster in the redemption department.

But on the whole, I enjoyed it a lot–especially given that it was a total Id read that still let me feel very smart for being able to appreciate it. šŸ˜‚

5 Comments »

Go Small So I Don’t Go Home

I’m giving myself permission to write very short comments on books, so I don’t freeze up and write nothing. I’ve actually been enjoying some romance again! My thanks to the menopause subreddit. šŸ˜‚

Love Lessons by Sarina Bowen. Book who-the-hell-knows of the “Brooklyn Bruisers” series.

I hate the “teach me to be sexy” plotline so much, I almost skipped this completely. But the relationship is drawn with a light touch and some good banter that made it fun.

Downsides: So tired of all the former couples crowding around in this series. To be fair, it’s not all, but it’s still a lot.

Upsides: I liked that the determinedly ordinary Joe ,tough guy hero has fabric sensitivity — perfect for the fashionista heroine to help him with. He’s also dyslexic and it’s not a big plot point.

Unfortunate: The hero’s last name is Crikey, and every time I read it I thought of a line from the Bonzo Dog Doodah Band: “Oh crikey, you rotter. Don’t punish me.” (Which actually fits so well, perhaps Bowen is a Bonzo fan?)

A Gift of Luck by Sarah Wynde. Book 5 of the Tassamara series.

A letdown. Really implausible plot leads to half the book being a Disney World travelogue for the wealthy. Very little spark between the two leads and a overdrawn stereotypical villain. And a whole lot of former couples hanging around! The blurb says “A little ghost story, a little mystery, and a lot of romance” and “a little mystery” is the only true part.

Cry For the Moon by Anne Stuart. Standalone.

One of her older, kinda bananapants Harlequin romances, though certainly not as weird as some. Some parts haven’t aged well, but the chemistry between the main characters is on point.

16 Comments »

Not a review of In The Lives of Puppets

I’ve finished it now, and though I thought some elements of the second half of the book were less strong that the first, I continued to love the characters and was very glad I’d read it.

Except for something that bothered me, and that was the acknowledgments, which are some of the most bittersweet I’ve ever read. It’s very clear that Klune had to change something about the book and it was greatly upsetting to him. And I’ve been kind of gently stewing over this, wondering what about writing a book many loved made him so unhappy. It really put a damper on my enjoyment, thinking maybe it was supposed to be a much sadder book. (There’s an intensely sad short prequel called Reduce! Reuse! Recycle!)

For once (lately) the internet helped! Someone asked this same question at Reddit and though I haven’t been able to verify the answer, it makes perfect sense. And thankfully, it’s one that leaves me completely at peace with the book as it is. (Although perhaps it makes the author something of an asshole? I think I’m passed the point of being furious with people for just being something of an asshole.)

1 Comment »

Celebrate Something or Other

I don’t have a TBR review for “celebration” today but I’m going to celebrate that I’m reading In the Lives of Puppets by TJ Klune and just loving it! I tried The House in the Cerulean Sea three times because it was so beloved, and then Under the Whispering Door and I was pretty sure Klune’s books of this type were Not For Me.

But AztecLady loved In the Lives of Puppets so much I decided to give him one more try, and it was the charm. The characters are so lovable, the setting so fascinating and mysterious, the somewhat dark humor thoroughly tickling my funny bone. Perhaps I’ll even try Cerulean Sea a fourth time!

I feel bad about reviewing so little this year. In truth, like many of us as we age, I’ve been moving somewhat away from romance, and a great many of the books on my TBR no longer appeal. Still plenty of romance authors I enjoy, but I don’t necessarily have much new to say about the books or genre. And I’ve been prioritizing other kinds of reading challenges.

But I don’t want to lose touch with people, especially since we’ll be closing down the romancelandia.club instance. šŸ˜ž I’m really sad about it but my admin/hub can only manage his mental health since the election by staying far away from social media. So I’ll try to keep contributing a bit here so people can still find me. And I did sign up for the 2026 TBR Challenge because hope springs eternal. šŸ˜‚

11 Comments »

Bitter Karella Hits the Nail on the Head – Again

See the full thread here.

Leave a comment »

TBR Challenge: Whispering Wood by Sharon Shinn

The Theme: Change of Plans

How This Fits: Val wants nothing more than to go home, but she’s persuaded to stay in the city. Hijinks ensue.

Published in 2023, this is a late return to Shinn’s ā€œElemental Blessingsā€ series. I read the first four books between 2015 and 2019, so the details aren’t sharp for me, but the set-up was explained well enough that I didn’t feel lost. Briefly, this society is organized around five ā€œelementsā€: air/soul, fire/mind, water/blood, earth/flesh and wood/bone. Everyone is born under an element that heavily influences their character. (A GoodReads reviewer named Liz calls this the “What if the elements determined your flavor of neurodivergence? series” and she’s got a point.)

Our protagonist Val is the sister of a previous hero, and she’s reluctantly attending his coronation as king of Welce. She’s a hunti (wood) person, as we hear endlessly–hating pubic attention and large events, and craving routine and the comforts of home. She also has a lot of anger towards her much older brother, who she feels abandoned her. Somehow he persuades her to stay awhile, and she’s befriended by his vivacious daughter Corene (a previous heroine) and discovers that her very best friend Sebastian is also in the city, though apparently up to no good. Oh, those sly and wily sweelas! (The constant harping on elements gets pretty annoying in fact, like living in an entire society thoroughly committed to astrology. But we do see growth for Val in the end. )

The plot is largely political intrigue and adventure, but eventually a very slow burn romance heats up (in a closed door fashion) between Val and Sebastian. We don’t really get to know him well or see why he’s in love with her, but her intelligence and practicality turn out to make her an excellent companion during a dangerous adventure. For me, her autistic coding was pretty relatable, and I enjoyed seeing her allow her experiences to change her.

On the whole though, the book isn’t great. Just technically, there are some errors and the ebook doesn’t seem well produced. There’s an unsavory subplot involving destitute Welce women being recruited as wives for a neighboring country that values youth more than anything. I don’t think much of a king who supports that plan instead of implementing societal changes, and I guess I’m glad I’m not especially fond of the previous books so that doesn’t break my heart. And in general, it just lacks focus and oomph. Sadly, I don’t think self-publishing her own books is doing Shinn any favors.

6 Comments »

Well well, look who’s inside again.

My husband and daughter and I watched Bo Bunham’s “Inside” for the… I dunno, sixth time? I was really enjoying sharing it as a family, laughing together, and my daughter picking out the instrumental themes. (She inherited her father’s excellent ear — I got one before they did and what a triumph!)

But afterwards they were discussing all the ways life has changed since then and how removed it feels and it depressed the fuck out of me. Because in so many ways, I’m still stuck here in the house.

3 Comments »

Recurring motifs in my reading, 9/25

Being given a white feather.

“Our Town.”

Schools in New Hampshire.

Three sisters and a cherry orchard.

Catholicism.

4 Comments »

Recurring motifs in my reading 8/25

Femme fatales.

Woodworkers.

Stories with significant playlists. (Last month too.)

Bed hogs.

5 Comments »

Outlier by Susie Tate

Oh dear. This is third in a series of fun “id” reads, and I was looking forward to it because recurring character Vicky is autistic. But it took the maligned heroine/regretful hero/protective trope several bridges too far for me.

The story overlaps somewhat with the previous book, Gold Digger, and the characters from the previous books run rampant. Vicky is a successful businesswoman, working with the hero from book one and getting assistance from the heroine from book two — also soon to be her sister-in-law — with the social aspects of her work. She’s also got a crush for the first time in her life, on Mike, the brother of book one’s heroine. They’ve known each other since they were little, but Mike has never understood Vicky’s odd silences and seeming aloofness; as a craftsman whose two best friends are rich (Vicky’s half-brother is also a Duke — sorry I can’t draw you a family tree) Mike has a chip on his shoulder about snooty rich girls, and he completely misinterprets Vicky’s attempts to tell him how she feels.

I’ll give props for Vicky not having what I call romance hero/ine autism — the kind where the character is quirky or intriguing without having any major life challenges. Vicky is gifted and has a photographic memory, but she also has significant issues with food, sensory needs, and intense meltdowns. It’s a fairly stereotypical depiction, but feels reasonably emotionally authentic.

But oh my goodness, does this book put poor Vicky through a wringer. She has a ghastly family history, and she hasn’t grasped that many of the people who came unwillingly into her life are actually very fond of her. And when these fond people, including Mike, discover how horribly Vicky’s been treated, it’s an orgy of regret and sorrow. It’s so much emotional overload I don’t know how Vicky can bear it, and sometimes it feels infantalizing to her.

I was also really bugged by the classic romance ending of lots of babies from everyone. We never see Vicky have a moment of concern about pregnancy or motherhood, something many autistic women agonize over for multiple reasons. (Sensory concerns, fear of being overwhelmed, concern about genetics, etc.) I think the book could really have used a good sensitivity reader. I didn’t hate it, but it could have been better.

2 Comments »

Jade Threadbear

a creative journal

SweetSavageFlame

Old School Romance From Avon to Zebra

'Nathan Burgoine

mostly short queer fiction from a tall queer guy

Sweet Savage Flame

Old School Romance From Avon to Zebra

Celebrity Readers

A Blog for Readers Who Can't Blog Good

Something More

my extensive reading

...Burns Through Her Bookshelf

Voracious reader, book lover, intermittant blogger, audiologist. These things are some of me, but not the sum of me.

Cate Marsden.

Love and Zombies. And books. And infrequent updates.

Book Thingo

Reading (mostly) romance books down under

Shallowreader

Hidden Depths

Olivia Dade

Bawdy romcoms with a big ♄.

Flight into Fantasy

Reviews, book thoughts and opinions of one omnivorous reader.

Her Hands, My Hands

The vagaries of my mind, the products of my hands. Not always safe for work.

dabwaha

64 books. 1 Champion. Get your game on.

Stop the STGRB Bullies

Your hypocrisy is showing

Blue Moon

Audiobook reviews and book reviews. Occasional opining.

Miss Bates Reads Romance

ā€œMiss Bates…had never boasted either beauty or cleverness. Her youth had passed without distinction, and her middle of life was devoted to the care of a failing mother, and the endeavour to make a small income go as far as possible. And yet she was a happy woman..." Emma, Jane Austen

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started