Today marks six years since Dannica was taken from me. Her life ended this evening, November 14th, 2012. The life I’d lived up to that point ended and the person I had been died then, too. The boundaries of this writing space I’ve created only allow one aspect of who I am to exist. However, like a ball of wire, my experience of Dannica’s death is inextricably connected to all of my experiences and every other person in my life and yet I’m not able to speak of those things. Some days, my whole life hurts, not only because Dannica died, but because it’s all connected, and it isn’t just about her anymore, or just me. Sometimes, I don’t know quite how to move forward without bringing it all with me.
It’s been so long, six years, and it’s still so new, like yesterday. Both are equally true as are the many ways one could possibly feel as the result of one or the other being true on its own. The world in general has decided that six years is a very long time, indeed, to be feeling like it’s still so new.
Some have suggested that I learn to be more at home in the quiet, empty spaces instead of uncomfortably trying to fill them. Others have suggested that instead of trying to create happiness I need to become intimately acquainted with and truly accepting of the wounding nature of life. Still others have suggested it is now time for me to move into my power. I don’t know what that means. Some days I’m still doing well to move into the next room.
In daily life, others’ comments frequently convince me it’s best to keep more things to myself; it’s best not to mention my daughter so much anymore, or my struggles in life or my thoughts about those things or, heaven forbid, my feelings. It’s so much easier to be quiet. Invisible. I’ve begun to feel protective of this grief; that it is precious because it is my connection to my daughter, that it is too personal sometimes to let out of me or to share with someone I’m not sure will treat it with the respect it deserves. I pull it close to my heart and hold it tenderly there most of the time now.
Most of my life I’ve felt the dark pull of Autumn, giving me permission and urging me to move inward, to become quiet, to rest, to silently celebrate the passing of another season. This is the energy I was born into and the energy my daughter Dannica died into. It is a sacred, sacred time for me. Lately, I’ve spent time reading the writing of others who’ve experienced similar losses. While the death of a child may not be uncommon, I’m convinced it will always be the most painful thing a parent can experience whether it happens once or many times. It is somehow and sadly comforting to me to remember I am not alone in this experience or in this pain or in this changed way in which I now view the world around me.
For now, I’d like to share the writing of Frances Gunther, wife of American journalist John Gunther, excerpted from John’s memoir Death Be Not Proud (1949). Mrs. Gunther writes here in response to the death of her 17-year-old son, Johnny. She expresses so much of what fills my heart today and most of my days:
My grief, I find, is not desolation or rebellion at universal law or deity. I find grief to be much simpler and sadder. Contemplating the Eternal Deity and His Universal Laws leaves me grave but dry-eyed. But a sunny fast wind along the Sound, good sailing weather, a new light boat, will shame me to tears: how Johnny would have loved this boat, this wind, this sunny day! …
Missing him now, I am haunted by my own shortcomings, how often I failed him. I think every parent must have a sense of failure, even of sin, merely in the remaining alive after the death of a child. One feels that it is not right to live when one’s child has died, that one should somehow have found the way to give one’s life to save his life. Failing there, one’s failures during his too brief life seem all the harder to bear and forgive. How often I wish I had not sent him away to school when he was still so young that he wanted to remain at home in his own room, with his own things and his own parents. How I wish we had maintained the marriage that created the home he loved so much. How I wish we had been able before he died to fulfill his last heart’s desires: the talk with Professor Einstein, the visit to Harvard Yard, the dance with his friend, Mary.
These desires seem so simple. How wonderful they would have been to him. All the wonderful things in life are so simple that one is not aware of their wonder until they are beyond touch. Never have I felt the wonder and beauty and joy of life so keenly as now in my grief that Johnny is not here to enjoy them.
Today, when I see parents impatient or tired or bored with their children, I wish I could say to them, But they are alive, think of the wonder of that! They may be a care and a burden, but think, they are alive! You can touch them—what a miracle! You don’t have to hold back sudden tears when you see just a headline about the Yale-Harvard game because you know your boy will never see the Yale-Harvard game, never see the house in Paris he was born in, never bring home his girl, and you will not hand down your jewels to his bride and will have no grandchildren to play with and spoil. Your sons and daughters are alive. Think of that—not dead but alive! Exult and sing.
All parents who have lost a child will feel what I mean. Others, luckily, cannot. But I hope they will embrace them with a little added rapture and a keener awareness of joy.
I wish we had loved Johnny more when he was alive. Of course we loved Johnny very much. Johnny knew that. Everybody knew it. Loving Johnny more. What does it mean? What can it mean, now?
Parents all over the earth who lost sons in the war have felt this kind of question, and sought an answer. To me, it means loving life more, being more aware of life, of one’s fellow human beings, of the earth.
It means obliterating, in a curious but real way, the ideas of evil and hate and the enemy, and transmuting them, with the alchemy of suffering, into ideas of clarity and charity.
It means caring more and more about other people, at home and abroad, all over the earth. It means caring more about God.
I hope we can love Johnny more and more till we too die, and leave behind us, as he did, the love of love, the love of life.

How I miss you Dannica, my beautiful, beautiful girl…
June 16, 1994 ~ November 14, 2012
~*~

