The people at The First U.P. Church of Crafton Heights are spending much of our time in 2023-2024 looking at the story of God’s people as recorded in the New Testament book of Acts. We engage in this series of messages convinced of the fact that God’s power changes apparently small and nondescript groups of people into a force that will change the world in ways that are reflective of the love and justice of Jesus. On July 28, we remembered the day that Paul was arrested in Jerusalem. You can read about it in Acts 21 & 22.
To hear this message as preached in worship, please use the player below:
To participate in worship via YouTube, please use this link:
The last time we saw the Apostle Paul, he’d just arrived in Jerusalem after a long stint in Gentile territory. We watched him meet with the Apostles, who blessed and authenticated his ministry among people who hadn’t been raised as Jews but came to love Jesus anyway. When we left him, Paul was heading to the Jewish Temple with a few other folks to participate in a religious ceremony. We noted that while Paul welcomed non-Jews to worship Jesus, there’s never any indication that he stopped practicing the faith of his youth. Sure, he may frame a few ideas differently now, but he believes his life has credibility and continuity.
Unfortunately, Paul doesn’t last a week in Jerusalem. You heard what happened – a mob comprised of diehard religious folks were energized by a lie and Paul nearly paid for it with his life. These folks accused Paul of antisemitism and of corrupting Jewish worship by bringing non-Jews into the Temple.
Now I know, I know that it’s hard to believe in these enlightened days of the 21st century, but here we see a scene from more than 2000 years ago wherein a few folks repeated a lie louder and louder until it got a crowd whipped into a frenzy that was murderous in its intent. Luke, our chronicler, points out the half-truth that was present, but it seems as though there is no stopping the mob now, and they beat Paul to within an inch of his life. The entire scene reminds me of that old saying, “a lie can travel halfway around the world while the truth is still putting on its shoes”
Fortunately, the Romans had anticipated scenes just such as this unfolding, and they’d built the fortress Antonia adjacent to the Temple. That guaranteed the presence of heavy force if things threatened to get out of hand. The tribune leading that group of centurions intervened, not so much because he cared who Paul was, but because as an ambitious officer in Caesar’s Legions, he was not about to let a civil disturbance sully his resume.
The tribune carts Paul off toward the barracks, where it becomes apparent that the soldier has no idea what’s really happening. When Paul speaks, it’s obvious that this tribune has been operating under an “all you people look alike to me” mentality.
Using very elegant Greek, Paul demonstrates to the Roman that he’s not the Egyptian terrorist that was reported to have been in the area. Instead, he says, he’s just a Jewish man embroiled in a religious dispute with other Jews. The tribune seems to indicate, “Well, if that’s all it is, then there’s no danger to the Empire here” and he permits Paul to address the crowd.
At this point, Paul switches to the local language – either Aramaic or Hebrew – and that quiets the crowd in a hurry. We didn’t hear the entirety of Paul’s speech this morning, but you heard the beginning, where he said, “I am a Jew…” He doesn’t say “I was a Jew” or “I used to be Jewish…” “I am a Jew.” As we mentioned last week, Paul saw no conflict between his practice and upbringing as a Jewish man and his identity as an Apostle of Jesus Christ.
And while we didn’t read the bulk of Paul’s address to the crowd, you’ve heard it before. It’s a retelling of that day that Paul met Jesus on the road to Damascus. We often call this “Paul’s conversion story”, but here it’s plain to see that while that experience fundamentally altered the trajectory of Paul’s life, it did not mean that he forsook his upbringing and culture. This story is so profoundly meaningful for Paul and the early church that it shows up three times in the book of Acts. We’ll have a chance to hear it again in chapter 26.
What can we learn from this description of the riot in the Temple? Why did Luke record it, and how can it inform our lives in 2024?
Let’s start by being attentive to the crowd that turned into a mob. Presumably, most of those folks were fine people – yet they became energized by a lie. It was, of course, a convenient lie in that it fit a narrative that seemed attractive to them. Like many people before and after them, these folks had been conditioned to assume that “we” are the bee’s knees, and that “they” are less than “we” are. “They” are a threat! “They” will ruin everything. Here, the rumor goes, Paul had defiled the community by bringing one of “them” with him into holy space.
This morning it strikes me that the “they” with whom the worshipers in Jerusalem are so furious are Gentiles who would seek to get close to God apart from the Law that had shaped the Jews for centuries. In their haste to expel those they label as “other”, these good people trample all over the Law they claim to exalt and respect.
I’m thinking specifically of the ninth commandment – one of the top ten. “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor”, read one of the tablets mentioned in Exodus 20. Apparently, one of the most important things that we can do, says God, is to avoid speaking lies about other people.
In the 2000 years since the book of Acts was written, there have been some wonderful attempts by people who follow Jesus to help us understand what the Law says and means. We Presbyterians have collected many of them in an underutilized resource called The Book of Confessions. In 1562 some folks in Germany were looking for a new Sunday School curriculum for their kids, and so they wrote what we call today The Heidelberg Catechism. It’s a series of questions and answers that the kids can repeat and memorize in order to learn to live the Jesus way.
This week I came across a modern translation of question #112 in the Heidelberg Catechism. It reads,
What is required in the ninth commandment?
I must not give false testimony against anyone, twist no one’s words, not gossip or slander, nor condemn or join in condemning anyone rashly and unheard.
Rather, I must avoid all lying and deceit as the devil’s own works, under penalty of God’s heavy wrath.
In court and everywhere else, I must love the truth, speak and confess it honestly, and do what I can to defend and promote my neighbor’s honor and reputation.
Isn’t that a helpful exploration of that commandment? I think that we can quickly agree that the mob gathered in Jerusalem on that day so long ago had lost sight of God’s desire for truth, but that’s ancient history at this point.
What about us? What if we were to use this tool to teach children as a litmus test for what we say, or text, or post, or imply? Have I joined in condemning someone else rashly? Do I avoid all lying and deceit – not merely something that might pass my own lips, but in the conversations and culture that surrounds me? Do I do what I can to promote my neighbor’s honor and reputation? In my home? At work? On social media?
As we move through these days of national and global upheaval, tensions are high and fear is amplified. Can we, as the people of God, choose to embrace the truth and reject lies – even those lies that make us feel better about ourselves, our candidates, or our decisions about the ways that we spend our time and money? Can we, who claim to be motivated by the love of Jesus, commit ourselves to defending and promoting the reputation and honor of our neighbor? And as we do that, can we remember that Jesus seemed to have a pretty broad definition of the word “neighbor”?
Let’s now consider, briefly, the behavior of the Roman soldier. Here’s a man who didn’t care one bit about Jewish Laws or Jesus. Yet he came pretty close to a colossal mistake because he couldn’t be bothered to look past his own prejudices and stereotypes. He saw what he perceived to be a rabble-rouser, put him in chains, and ordered him shipped off to the brig.
It wasn’t until Paul spoke to him that he realized that Paul was not the Egyptian terrorist he’d assumed him to be, but rather a citizen of the Roman Empire. Had that tribune allowed Paul – a citizen – to be killed by a Palestinian mob, he’d have suffered some pretty dire consequences.
That leads me to reflect on how quick we are to use shorthand and to talk in generalities and conveniences. It’s so easy to speak of categories – immigrants, gang-bangers, lib-tards, or fascists! The danger is that if we think of one another as categories like this, it will be easier for us to dismiss as worthless so many who are made in God’s image. May God protect us from, and may we resolve to avoid, that casual clumping of people together for the purpose of vilifying and othering them.
Finally, let’s spend a few moments thinking about Paul in this situation. Here he stands, before the soldiers who’ve shackled him and the crowd that has beaten him, and he mounts his defense. What he offers as his defense is merely a story – the story of his life. He recounts his early life as a zealous Pharisee, his encounter with Jesus, and his commissioning to the Gentiles. In his telling, and in his life, we see Paul as a man who loves God far more than he loves his own ideas about God.
Bishop Will Willimon describes this as Paul’s “vocation”, and here we understand that word to mean not merely that which one does for a living, but rather “the way in which we respond to the commissioning of God upon our lives, the things God asks us to do as a part of God’s work in the world.”[1]
Paul’s vocation – like yours and mine – is to follow God to the places where God is active in the world. And here in Acts 21 and 22, Paul describes how his vocation led him to plenty of places where God surprised Paul – even among the Gentiles!
May we learn from this, and be able to grow in our own willingness to be led into new and different areas of God’s grace. May we commit ourselves today to this vocation of following Jesus closely, intimately, and expectantly. If we do so, we will bear witness – true witness – to the power of God that heals hearts, transforms the stranger into the neighbor, and enables us to live as those who are shaped by a passion for God’s love and justice each day. Thanks be to God for the witness of Paul, for the opportunity we have been given to bear witness as God’s people today. Amen.
[1] Interpretation Commentary on the Book of Acts, Westminster/John Knox 1988, p. 168-169.



