When the cancer returns, when that long-awaited promotion slips through your fingers, when this month’s bills go unpaid, when you wake up to another failed attempt at getting pregnant, it seems all people respond with the same four words: God has a plan.
You don’t even have to believe it to say it. I too, am guilty of tossing this one-liner out there in an effort to cool the disappointment. People sorrowfully stitch this phrase between “I’m so sorry” and “I love you,” in hopes that it somehow softens the blow of pain. And sadly, it doesn’t.
Because all I can think is when did I ever say, “God doesn’t have a plan?” The thought never entered my mind and the words never exited my mouth. I have spent years talking to God about His plan, trying to uncover it, trying to rid myself of it, and then trying to accept it. But never once, did I doubt it existed. Perhaps, it is so heavenly and I am so earthly that I fail to grasp even the most minuscule piece of His ways on this side of eternity. But my frail understanding of His plan does not negate its existence. I believe scripture – that includes every written prophecy, every recorded miracle, every mountain moved, every wave stilled, every story of a dead man walking. I believe it. I also believe that in each case there was a plan – a foreshadowing of the King, a crowd of witnesses, a problem so great, a storm so powerful, so that His story could overflow with redemption. I believe these things.
If you look at scripture, you will know that God’s perfect plan isn’t always enjoyable.
Ask Job. There’s 42 chapters full of a plan and the first 41 of them were excruciatingly painful. He lost every child he ever named, his land burned away, his crops, his servants, his entire flock ruined. And He felt God was silenced, that the Lord abandoned him.
I go east, but he is not there. I go west, but I cannot find him. I do not see him in the north, for he is hidden. I look to the south, but he is concealed. -Job 23:8-9
Look at the lepers. Exiled. Covered in seeping spots. No one could look at them for they were too disgusting for eyes to bear. But Jesus came to them in Luke 17. There was a plan of God. But no clean person stood on the other side of the fence shouting, “It’s okay, leper, God has a plan!” No leper would find hope in those words.
Take Jesus. God had a plan for him since the beginning; for He was born to die. God’s plan involved betrayal, denial, mockery, chains, and death. The cruelest death that has ever existed. The wages of sin could be paid no other way. And God knew that.
So to say that my suffering is a part of God’s plan, well, that can be equally painful and comforting to hear. How cruel it can seem that the God you love scripted this plan? How different our plan is from yours? How fallen our world is that Satan swings from the limbs of earth as a playground? How you beg for the testimony of Job 42 while living in chapter 1?
Please understand what I am saying: Every good and perfect thing is from God. Satan tries to rewrite our lives laced with pain and sometimes God allows it because it will make us good in His sight. But there is always healing, for Job is was double. For the lepers, it was a process. For Jesus, it was three days later. And for some, like Paul, healing waits for us, on a date, that God prescribed long before we were born.
I am willing to suffer in God’s plan, but please don’t correct my crying with empty phrases. Don’t tell me to have more faith, pray harder, or try again. No person has spent more time kneeling, praying and listening to God than my husband and me about His plan for our life. And the idea that this particular plan might not include children of our own can seem awfully cruel because the only One with the ability to provide them is the same One we choose to serve. And that makes belief in Him terribly difficult, but our hearts will sing no other name.
So Lord, whatever plan You have for us, we’ll claim it. And forgive us on the days when our hearts ache for what our flesh wants most. I know, that right now, You are grooming us, preparing us, for the road ahead. Thank You for having a plan when our plans fall short.








